HMC

Chicken & Mutton Shop in Gardiners Island

Butcher shop

Tony's Meat Market of Montauk

541 W Lake Dr, Montauk, NY 11954

Cafe

Gin Beach Cafe’

Pink Frog Cafe

Farmers' market

Amber Waves Farm, Market & Cafe

Montauk Farmer's Market

Fireplace Farm

East Hampton Farmers Market

Clothing Shop

Shine Free People

The Summer Shop

General Store

Martell's of Montauk

Book Shop

Homeport

Hardware Shop

Becker Home Center Inc.

Ice cream shop

The Sweet Spot

Sweet shop

Dylan's Candy Bar

Fudge N Stuff

Fruit and vegetable shop

Latham Farms

Top Rated Addresses in Gardiners Island

Montauk Manor
Hotel
Kenny's Tipperary Inn
Motel
Montauk Blue Hotel
Hotel
Amagansett IGA
Supermarket
East Hampton House Resort
Hotel
Brent's General Store
Deli
Georges Lighthouse Bar & Grill
Cafe
Daunt's Albatross Motel
Motel
Left Hand Coffee
Coffee shop
Sam's Star Island Yacht Club & Marina
Marina