La Mia Pizzeria Old Lyme

Holy cow... that was one incredibly delicious chicken cutlet bacon grinder!! Definitely was not expecting that!! As a chef, I’m very critical of properly made chicken cutlets - and this place NAILED it. Super fresh everything, and even the bread was fantastic... very friendly service. Highly recommend!!!

God bless this oasis off the highway, the wonderful staff, and the most amazing pizza I've had in a long, long time. Truly an underappreciated gem.

Pizza is my favorite food- and I love the creativity, crust, and passion for pizza at La Mia Pizzeria! I love the daily specials and their 2 slices and a can for $5 can not be beat for a lunch special. Their dessert section is always a nice treat and I’ve bought a bunch of the oreo truffles for an occasion one time because I wanted something delicious and homemade that looks great and tastes great and they were a huge hit. Love that they carry local soda and chips - supporting local is huge for me!

Local fave. I live around the corner and am so grateful to have a celiac-friendly option that is even more delicious (i think) than regular pizza!
Also would like to note the strikingly excellent personal customer service when you pick up. Not the overly chipper obligatory stuff but seriously i always leave feeling that positive rush of a thoughtful efficient mutually beneficial transaction. Thanks!

Originally a Da Vinci Pizzeria, La Mia is exactly what you hope for in a local pizza shop.

I order a *scallop and bacon pizza* exactly as it comes: conservatively--after having had pizza from five time zones in 10 US states--this is the BEST pizza I have ever had!

Everything is fresh, the crust is AMAZING (and I rarely appreciate crust) and the flavors blend and compliment each other amazingly well. But don't take my word for it! I couldn't keep it to myself (for my own health too, this pie is YUGE) so I got my coworkers to all try it too (they knew something had arrived, naturally you can smell the scallops) and now they're all in love. 10/10 would recommend!

Best pizza I've had in a long time. They said they got a new stove which explains how the bottom & crust were so perfectly cooked. I'll be back again soon.

We had three pizzas, cheese, sausage, and an eggplant. All three were delicious, all three are worth getting again. I am excited for the next time we decide on pizza!

Best pizza around and very friendly staff! Lots of options for specialty pizzas and great lunch special. Grinders are great as well!

Friendly staff, great pizza and a small town $5 "fast food" option that isn't just for lunch. Love this place.

The staff is incredible, the experience was wonderful and I love the pizza. Those guys deserve a bonus.

Best gluten free pizza I've ever had. And the woman working there went out of her way to help me.

Hearty, fresh salads. Crisp crust pizza with just enough toppings. And the cookies - crispy and chewy.

Awesome pizza. Great slices for lunch. Also love their calzones 😘

Pizza is nice and thin with great flavor! Good assortment of beverages too.

Great pizza, food and service. Pay them a visit when your in Old Lime. You won't regret it.!

I have had a lot of items here and have never been disappointed.very fresh food and the staff are friendly and helpful

Continuing the great pizza tradition in this spot starting with Mama Mia's take-out Pizzeria in the 1990's

It's a great place to stop and get a quick bite for lunch, great atmosphere,with also great staff.

Great place. Amazing food. You will not be disappointed!!!

Nice thin pizza crust at good prices