Cafora's Pizza Italian Restaurant

Have visited this place thrice and it has been awesome all the time. Delicious food with great serving size and warm welcome staff makes you feel like home. Accommodate people with special food requests. They have pizza theatre where you can watch cook making pizza. Order comes with warm bread and it is best tasting bread that i have ever tasted.

5 stars all the way around!!!! I love their food, the atmosphere is always GREAT and this is the BEST place to call if u need dinner in a hurry but don't feel like cooking!! Family owned and operated and pushing out Italian food like it's their business!!! I love this place!!

Great menu choices. A lot to choose from. It was jamming packed on a Sunday night which is a great sign.

I ordered the pene with mushrooms and gorgonzola. I started with the Italian wedding soup. The soup was perfect. Exactly what I would've wanted in an Italian wedding soup. Seasoned perfectly.

The pasta was perfectly cooked and the sauce had a tad bit of sweetness to it but not over powering. There wasn't much of a gorgonzola flavor but I was ok with that. It was delicious as it came.

The home baked bread they brought out was the PERFECT accompaniment. Cristy on the outside. Warm and soft inside.

The 2 servers, I believe Morgan and Christina (?), though it was packed, were delightful and attentive.

I've just moved to the area and am happy that this is nearby. I'm looking forward to the leftovers that are in my fridge for tonight. Portions were extremely generous.

Didn't get photos this time as I was too busy eating.

My family and I travel an hour and a half just to come here to eat. They have great food. Big portions. The waitress are always friendly and the place is always clean. We have 5 people in our family and we never have to wait long to be seated. My wife had the chicken parmesan, our 2 girls had the spaghetti and meatballs, my son had the pizza and fries and I had a steak pazone. Everything was delicious and the prices are reasonable.

Went here with my daughter, we got 10 wings, 2 sodas, and a small pizza. For $38. I thought that was pretty fair. There was a wait. Every table was full but I already knew that's how it is there. Very busy, it was a Saturday evening around 5:30. Service was very good as well.

If you live or visit anywhere within driving distance to Newfane, I STRONGLY recommend you stop in for a meal at Cafora's! They have a vast and extensive menu full of classic and original Italian meals!

Family owned and ran for 50+ years. Charming and quaint environment with extremely reasonable prices!

They even have a "CHUBBY CHALLENGE". If you can eat an entire Chubby in 30 minutes or less you can win a $10 gift certificate AND get on the Wall Of Shame!!!

I definitely will be coming in regularly to try more menu items! Lourie was a friendly and fun server who recommended an amazing meal for me. ❤

Food is always fabulous! The best linguine and clam sauce! But the service was slow, with not many customers in house. They had a lot of takeout, should have served us first.

Great pizza! This place didn't disappoint. Cozy restaurant in a cute small town. I was happy to see it busy. Excellent service too!

Great food. Friendly service. Small town family feel. We go often and have never been let down. I love the lasagna and French onion soup but their pizza and wings are great too. Nice selection of entrees.

Our first time here and definitely not our last.
Great service and food. Thank you!

You will love this food , from pizza to pasta or salads and sandwiches! You won’t be disappointed!

I really liked our waitress who helped us decide what to eat. She even helped us decide what we are going to eat next time we come.

Great food. Friendly staff. The best pizza around you will love it. The chicken parmesan and Hawaiian pizza with white sauce are also a great choice. The fish fry with spaghetti is real good too. I have never had anything bad.

Another great meal and our waitress, Kendall, was amazing. Very friendly and super efficient.

We had the pizza, it was great. Service was fast and everyone was very friendly. Definitely coming back. Saw their homemade fresh bread at another table that's something I'm going to remember to get next time.

As a tourist.... or a visitor, I'd say this place is "whatever". Lol it'll do. It's not fine dining by any means. The food is good, not great, but good. Same for the service and same for the atmosphere. It's good for the price. HOWEVER.... I think it DOES have the potential to "grow on you". I've been there twice, and enjoyed my experience better the second time around. Will probably change my review by the third or fourth time.

Great little Italian restaurant, super nice people, relaxing atmosphere.

I don't care how long we had to wait to get in, we would wait. So
now we often go before it gets crowded. There is a reason you have to wait, because the food is great, and a lot of people come. It gets crowded for a reason. Their food is excellent. Having grandparents from Italy I knew Italian tomato sauce; we had it every Sunday and Thursday growing up. I absolutely love any pasta with Cafora's Italian tomato sauce. My Mother loved their side salad, with raspberry vinaigrette and crumbly blue cheese. My family hasn't had one thing they didn't like.

Always wonderful. Very busy on Friday and Saturday

Their ponzones are filling and delicious!
Pizzas are full of flavor!
Wings are finger lickin' good!
Haven't been disappointed so far.
There truely is a reason it's a local favorite!