Gulotta's Pizza

I'm a young Rockford native on a quest to find the best pizza in Rockford, for all places I'll be trying a plain cheese pizza to be as unbiased as possible.
The pizza was all around excellent. The sauce was sweet, but not overly. The amount of cheese was perfect, not too much, not too little, and was not greasy. I'm pretty picky about pizza crust, but this was possibly my favorite crust of any pizza I've ever had, not doughy and not too hard. All aspects of the pizza compliment each other and blend together very well. Aside from the pizza, Nick was a great guy and pleasure to give my business to. The price is also unbeatable, 9$ for a large pizza. Places like this are what make Rockford great and seeing as Gulotta's is the first place I tried for this experiment, the rest of the pizza places in Rockford will be up against some stiff competition.

Nick is the best! So so nice, friendly and welcoming. Best pizza in town! Homemade fresh pizza dough every day! Mama Gulotta’s homemade pasta sauce is also fantastic. Been getting pizza and pasta at Gulotta’s for over 33 years same recipe and delicious taste EVERY TIME. Feel blessed to have Nick as part of our family for so long.

Nick is a pizza mensch. Our first pie last night - his "Supreme" was incredible. Excellent home made crust, sausage & sauce, really can't wait to have the leftovers today! This is pizza the way it should be done. Couldn't be happier we tried Gulotta's, we'll certainly be back, and recommend it highly. 5 stars all the way.

Ordered a pizza from here tonight and it was delicious! The owner was extremely friendly as well. We will definitely be ordering from here again! Pricing was very fair

While visiting my parents we ordered lasagna and garlic bread. It was the best ever! Perfect combination of meat, pasta, cheese and sauce. Already use and love Gulotta’s Pasta Sauce too. Nick is so awesome!

I’ve always wanted to try Gulatto’s Pizza and let me say I’m glad I did! I’ve lived in Rockford all my life and can’t believe it’s taken me this long to try food at this local gem! Pizza is DELICIOUS! The owner Nick, is so amazing and nice! He has such a passion for his business and you can tell he loves what he does! He makes everything by hand and you can definitely taste it in the pizza!

Great customer service and great pizza.
Definitely will be back for the lasagna.

The pizza here is literally the best in town! It is so tasty and delicious. You could tell the pizza is made from scratch because the flavor is very fresh and different (in a great way!) Also, Nick the owner is the most respectful and sweetest person! He remembers all his customers and it is always such a pleasure ordering from his family owned pizzeria. 100/10 on these yummy pizzas!! My favorite one has to be the peperoni and jalapeño. So delish!

I been wanting to try this place for a long time and just never have until tonight. This place is great and Nick definitely makes the experience better. The sauce and crust is exceptional. I'm glad I tried it, were absolutely coming back. THANKS NICK. 🇮🇹🤙👍

Gulatto’s Pizza in beautiful Rockford Illinois. Large everything minus anchovies. Nick Gulatto is a master pizza maker. Back up from Florida and you cannot get this type of delicious pizza there.

We have only eaten there twice but both times the food was exceptionally delicious. The owner is extremely friendly and he made our order exactly how we asked him to and he even showed the pizzas to us when we got there to make sure they were done exactly how we wanted. He advised us that they do sell the sauce that they use on their food and I went and bought a couple jars at schnucks, it's amazing! One of the only few good pizza places in Rockford. I highly recommend it and I will definitely be back!

I must say I’m new in the Rockford area and growing up & living in Chicago im used to eat very good pizza who doesn’t like Chicago Pizza 🍕 anyway I moved a couple months ago here to Rockford & I searched top rated pizza 🍕 and Guilotas Pizza had very good reviews & I must say ITS DELICIOUS 🤤 NICK THE OWNER IS A VERY DOWN TO EARTH HUMBLE MAN THAT HAS WON OUR FAMILY WITH HIS PIZZA ITS FRESH ITS CHEESY THE SAUCE IS INCREDIBLE TODAY WE WILL BE TRYING HIS LASAGNA THAT I DONT DOUBT ONE BIT ITS GOING TO BE DELICIOUS!!! I HIGHLY RECOMMEND GUILOTAS PIZZA TO ANYONE WHO WANTS DELICIOUS FRESH PIZZA ITS AMAZING 🤩 THIS IS PLACE ALSO IS CASH ONLY HIS PRICES ARE SO REASONABLE ASWELL!!!!

Nick thank you 🙏 God Bless your heart and family for making such delicious food 🙏

Growing up in Rockford, Gulotta's was a treat my whole life. I'm sure to get some when in town visiting my Dad who still raves about it. Nick is such a friendly & welcoming person. To the very few reviews not liking the pizza, I can say it's unlike any other: crust is a mix of freshly baked bread with a crispy outer layer, sauce is mild but distinct, and the cheese blend is also special. I would expect maybe 1 of 20 will not like, but for the rest of us, this pizza is otherworldly & a staple of my Rockford roots. Thanks Nick!!!

Family favorite for over 40 years. Nick makes great pizza and is such a friendly guy. The sausage on the pizza is amazing. P

Nick will always remember you. He is the nicest and friendliest guy and
will always talk to catch up for a minute. His food is delicious! My favorite is his Italian beef sandwich. His prices are excellent and so is his service.

We've been going to Gulotta's for over 30 years. Best pizza and lasagna in town. Nick is the nicest guy you will ever meet; we love him! George & Marie Navickis

My favorite pizza place! My dad started eating Gulotta's pizza before I was born and I've probably known the owner (Nick) my entire life. Everything is made by Nick, including the crust, the sauce, and even the sausage. The toppings go all the way to the edge so every piece is full of toppings, no leftover crust. Simply some of the best pizza you can find anywhere. It's cash only, carry out only but so worth it. Also, you can get Gulatta's pasta sauce at the East State St. Valli's!

Always great pizza for a great price. I have enjoyed it for many years. The owner is so very nice!

I've been coming here since I was a child. Great Pizza. Amazing customer service, Nick is just about the nicest owner of all time. The most underrated pizza place in the Rockford area.

My papa and granny would order from here all the time. I would come in here as a kid and I would see the mom and son cooking :)