Pickup's Pizza Company

We stopped on our way back home because it had good reviews and had parking for our trailer. So glad we did! Amazing pizza. Crispy browned cheesy edges and yummy sauce. The cheese bread was great. Friendly staff and very reasonable prices. For all the Denverites, it's better than Blue Pan. We will be back on our next trek west. Highly recommend stopping here!

Came across this gem of a pizza joint while pet sitting nearby for a friend. IMHO the pan pizza is 10/10. Coming from Chicago and Denver, I've certainly had my fair share of delicious pizza, but for Colorado, this takes the #1 spot. No joke. This is legit pan (almost Detroit style) pizza with perfectly standard sauce, solid cheese, amazing Italian sausage, and a delightfully crispy crust all around. Dare I say this beats Blue Pan [insert shrug emoji]

Pickups Pizza is the best! The hand made pizzas are delicious and the staff is always friendly and courteous. I've tried every pizza on the menu and they're incredible. We love the vibe of the restaurant and their choice of tunes, which is always at the perfect volume. Best place for take out, I mean Pick-up, in Eagle, CO!

Hands down the best pizza in the valley. An absolute amazing product and not overpriced for quality. Everyone I have try it falls in love. Every pizza I have had is better than the next, but the lasagna is top-notch! Definitely the crowd pleaser in my family! If you have leftovers somehow, this is simply the best reheated pizza EVER! 4 mins in the air fryer and your back in heaven. It's nice to get East Coast flavor out here in colorado.. It's not a thin New York slice, but it's the next best thing for sure. It's like New York and an affair with chicago. Try it, you won't be disappointed, just sad you didn't sooner! One loyal and happy customer here!

Very pleasantly surprised by this place as it turned out to be one of the best detroit style pizzas, maybe even one of the best pizzas, I’ve ever had. The crust was perfectly cooked and crispy. We had one of the white sauces ones and although I was skeptical about sprouts on a pizza, it was excellent. Definitely recommend this place if you’re passing through and can’t wait to come back!

Finally good thin crust!!! I am so excited to finally find good thin crust pizza. Not only in the Valley but Colorado. Pizza here is laughable but I think these guys might be from Chicago. You can tell there’s care in the sauce.

We love the pizza, shishitos, and salads. My favorite topping is the roasted garlic, mmmm, delicious!

Love to get Pickup’s Pizza every time we come to Eagle. Especially like that they deliver to Bonfire Brewery!
I recommend The Goat. Ours has pineapple added. Yummy.

Definitely the best pizza we’ve had out of Chicago. Probably even better than some places IN Chicago lol. We got the thin crust pele and the md. Also the pan crust cheesey bread is soo good. Def would order here again.

The place is not looking to be pretentious, the food is on point, the ingredients are fresh and flavorful. The thin crust is my favorite but with the pan crust, you can feel a certain butter like flavor in it.
They also offered gluten free options!

Absolutely the best pizza we’ve had in a long time. Probably since my wife and I moved from Denver, CO. These guys know how to make a good pizza. We order truckin delicious cheesy bread and large Hondo pan pizza. The pizza came out exactly at the time they stated it would despite how busy they were. If I could give it 6 stars I would. Highly recommend it! Good job boys!

My family and I visited this amazing place for the first time during dinner. The lady working front counter told us it would take up to 50 minutes to get our pizza, but it only took 25 at most. The pizza has fresh spinach and mushrooms and the sauce is amazing but the best part was the crust it was half crisp and the other half fluffy, perfect combo makes my mouth water just thinking about it. Eating at this pizza shop would satisfy your taste buds any day.

Great pizza, the workers are always nice, and the vibe is great.

I was only in town for the evening and I googled pizza, this was at the top of the list. This was very good pizza. I was with 2 other people and we all ordered a different pizza so I was able to try both crusts offered. The thin was perfectly crispy, and the pan style was cooked perfectly, not doughy. All of the ingredients tasted fresh and the pizzas came out pretty quickly. I would highly recommend Pickups to anyone traveling through Eagle, and if you live in Eagle you should eat there every day.

Great pizza! Just a last minute stop by, but turned out to be a great decision.

Great “Detroit-style” pizza. Highly recommend if you’re in or near Eagle. Online ordering is a little cumbersome, but worked after a few tries. They deliver for free to Bonfire Brewery—highly recommend both. We got a small pizza—it’s 4 3”x4” pieces. The large is twice as big. Also got a salad which was good.

Just picked up two pizzas, both were perfect. The entire staff were awesome. This place deserves your business. All local fresh ingredients. It's a top of the line pizza in an awesome environment! I'll be back soon!

Best pizza I have had in a long time! Friendly service!
Came to Eagle for a dog show and found this cool little pizza parlor, best unplanned stop we ever made! Super happy we made the decision to look for pizza! Very yummy, you will not be displeased! BUT make you own pizza, it's preferred and everything made was yummy! Very recommended!!!

Highly recommend this place. Super friendly staff, eager to help and make conversation. I’m from out of state, way out of state, and the guy was very welcoming and eager to help me decide on the right option for me. Pizza was really good and I recommend the deep dish. I think it’s awesome they have a delivery connection set up with a local brewery. I would eat here again and recommend.

The pan pizza is one of the best pizzas I've ever had. We stopped on our way back to Denver. Just wanted pizza and this showed up as close to us. Total gem. Total surprise. Delicious.