Pizza Town Pizzeria

Awesome food, great service, homey atmosphere, reasonable prices. The owner & staff are friendly and attentive. You feel like family when you’re there. My new favorite is the cheesy garlic bread with a side of the most amazing marinara sauce. Pizza is yummy too. Love this place!

Traveled from Lancaster to meet family at a halfway point from Milroy. Great choice! Super super super friendly service. Food was delicious and the facility was super clean! Will definitely go back again. Menu is huge and would like to try more than pizza and appetizers!

Ok, so whatever they do to make the meatballs so good, God bless them! I have eaten there and also had takeout, and I have always ordered the stuffed shells with meatballs, bread and salad. You can't beat it.
I don't live there, but am looking to move that way soon, and will not only patronize, but will also endorse this fine establishment!

Local eclectic and authentic Italian restaurant. I moved to the area recently and live really close so I have made 3 takeout orders so far.. every single one has been awesome! The pizza is DELICIOUS, totally cheesy and the right amount of greasy, just everything you want in a good pizza imo. The subs are top notch too, the bread is handmade and wonderful. The ZEPPOLIS are just spectacular, a must try. I am also obsessed with the corn nuggets cuz these are some of the best! I can't wait to explore more of their menu with each order. I am such a happy repeat customer, a GREAT little place, don't let its outside look and demeanor deter you. The people inside are wonderful chefs and so nice!

Was heading home from a 3hr road trip and stopped here for something to eat. The food was incredible! Had the pizza slices and garlic knots. Absolutely wonderful atmosphere as well! Definitely considering making the 1.5hr drive from home back here sometime!

Not food related-on a recent evening our mother , driving at night, became lost and stopped at Pizzatown asking for directions. The kind proprietors gave her a sandwich and drink, and called for help when she sustained an injury. These good folks acted as God's angels to our mom. Many thanks.

In town visiting a campground and found this awesome local restaurant. We first got a pizza for take out. It was so good we had to go back to eat inside. The garlic knots were the best I've had! I couldn't stop eating them. Pizza was delicious. They did have many other options on menu to try. Next time we pass through, we will definitely be back to try the dinner menu.

Awesome food and great service. Our meals came packaged for dine in with to go plates, which made sense from the very large portions we were served.

Ordered carry out. Ready out of the oven exactly on time. Pizza was good, less sauce than typical.

Great food, very nice friendly owners, always look forward to our visit there. Highly recommend!!

This place has AMAZING pizza. And I do say that whole heartedly, the prices are a little costly, but I’ll pay that for the quality of the pizza. I can’t speak on the other food here because I have never tried it, however, I’ve heard good things. The service is a 9/10 I wouldn’t say super friendly, but they’ve never treated me bad. Just is my opinion on first impressions. I promise you the crust alone makes me want to come back everyday. Also, the garlic knots are amazing!!!!!

This place is a little jem.The food is fresh an delicious. As well as staff is super nice and friendly.Will definitely come back when in town.

Great pizza more toppings on the pizza than you can imagine. One slice is like eating a meal.

Best pizza you will find around. It blows all the other Italian restaurants out of the water. You definitely get what you pay for.

Could not stop laughing with the owners! The food was great! Atmosphere was very cute and homey!

It is hard to find that great Sicilian style pizza or that NY style, but Pizza Town make one of the best I've ever had. The pizza crust is simply outstanding! They have a great menu, their food is amazing and Sal is an awesome owner and chef along with the entire family and staff. I highly recommend Pizza Town and I'm Italian (actually Sicilian) and you know how picky we are about our pizza! In fact, I would drive all the way from North Carolina just to get a slice from one of those pies!! Keep up the amazing job, Pizza Town! 5 Stars all day! Ciao.

Loved the food. Excellent portions of greasy, delicious food. Don't go here if you're on a diet but definitely go if you want some great food.

Absolutely loved the salad with tuna fish! I received a massive amount of food and took a hoagie home for my husband that was enormous and he loved as well! Friendly, wonderful, employees and my grandson Luke met and enjoyed his time with little Emma very much!! We camp at little Buffalo and this will be our go to place on our way to camp! Thank you!!!

I went from a 1 star review to a 5. I had originally shared my overall experience as "every time I order from them, my orders are messed up". The owner had reached out to me and we talked about things that should've been done instead and she also extended some info that I did not know and now I know better than to judge before reviewing over a bad day. They are a wonderful place, and it's obviously run by a wonderful family as well. I appreciate them reaching out to us to discuss things civilly.❤

Awesome wait staff, delicious food, family atmosphere, great prices!