Paul's Pizza on 4th formerly DiCarlo's Pizza

These guys rock. I'm an out-of-towner who misses the crunch and the great taste of Dicarlo's. I asked these guys to sell me a Take-N-Bake so I could finish baking it and preparing at home in Akron. They completely squared me away. It's two days later and the Dicarlo's pizza tastes like it's fresh from the oven (because it's fresh from my oven) Get you some of that next time you're in T-Town. Thanks Guys!

Best pizza ever!🍕 Some of the best pizza in the valley no doubt. I love coming dahn everytime I'm in Toronto. Yinz have never disappointed when it came to pizza.
Edit: This was formerly DiCarlo's. I believe they have rebranded the restaurant to Paul's Pizza on 4th.

No other pizza tastes quite like DiCarlos. Plenty of cheese, and a nice crunch on the crust. Our family enjoys it at least once a week. Friendly crew. If you call and order it is ready when they give you a time.

Very unique pizza. I'm not from southern Ohio so when I first experienced this pizza with my gf/now wife I was a little confused as to why the cheese and pepperoni weren't cooked. However, I've come to love this pizza and we make it a priority to order 2 sheets anytime we come down to visit her family to bring back with us. The crust is simply unbelievable and the sauce is outstanding. They also seem to be one of the few places where you can still get a decently priced pizza. If I ordered the same pizza in NEO it would cost me 4 times as much. I highly recommend dicarlos.

Mazza family enjoy

Dicarlos Pizza should be the only pizza ever to be eaten. All other pizza doesn’t even belong in the same category as this pizza. Square slices just as pizza should be with the cheese added after baking and melting in the box under its own heat! I feel like Ralphie in a Christmas story describing a red rider. Just do yourself a favor and get a slice of this pizza. What stop at a slice just get a tray and thank me later.

Best pizza in the Valley!!!

DiCarlos is the best! Everytime I stop in Toronto I order a tray with Xtra Cheese and Pepperoni! The team there really puts their hearts into the pizza, you can taste it! Absolutely Awesome!
Much Love,
Sabo

It's been a long time since I've been there and the pizza 🍕 was fantastic I only got cheese only now. Can't wait till my next order ☺.

Best pizza I've ever had, anywhere, hands down. Grew up eating it and now that I moved away from OH. it's the best reason to make a trip back (family aside)
Do miss the old style boxes that came wrapped in red rubber bands though!

Hands down my favorite square pizza in the valley. All Dicarlos shops are very good but this one is the best 16 slice Trey's that are affordable. Extra Cheese served on the side.The Best

Excellent! They've been the best for decades with their natural and fresh ingredients, delicious crust. And their great customer service is always a plus!

My family and I loves DiCarlos pizza.

Best. Pizza. Ever. The service is casual, so don't get offended.

Truly excellent! I know good pizza when I experience it. I may not get out this way often, but it is my intention when I do I will be sure to hit up DiCarlos.

The food is always great. We order pizza, salads, and soups when available.

Absolutely love DiCarlo's pizza. Whenever I am in town I try to get some.

My man and my daughter love to go on pizza dates here, they’re so cute talking in my backseat about the pizza 🍕 ❤ 😃 I love you guys very much

One of my first stop when I come home to visit. Great up on this pizza and have yet to find another place that is comparable.

Best pizza ever, every time I come up from Georgia I gotta have Dicarlos love it can't find nothin like it in the south !