Mill Creek Inn

This is a great stop just off the lake. They have amazing Bloody Mary's and the price is great for what you get. We never order food if we get the big Bloody Mary. Service is great and the outdoor deck is awesome on a nice day.

This place has amazing food, friendly staff and a great atmosphere for dining or visiting the bar to watch a game. Highly recommended.

We stopped in here based on a townies recommendation and we’re not disappointed! The atmosphere was laid back and the beer selection was good. The best part was the food!! All four of our meals were thoroughly enjoyed. The waitress pointed me toward the mahi tacos and they were thoroughly enjoyed! We left here full and happy!

Such a great time! We’re new to Buffalo and heard Mill Creek was the place to go. The food was soooo yummy, the service was great and quick. I had my two kids with so I’m always worried about it taking a while and them getting wild. Not a problem! A lot of kids there too. Definitely will be back!

Chef Aiden is the best cook in the world. My food was amazing. Service was amazing and chef Aiden absolutely perfected the dish with love and care. I know his name because I asked my server. I would love to shake his hand because only then will I have been touched by greatness. It may have been the best food my palate has ever come into physical contact with. This experience was truly remarkable and if I could go back in time in a flux capacitor to tell my younger self about this restaurant sooner I truly would. I cannot believe the quality, time, love and care put into the food. Chef Aiden if you are reading this, please know you are remarkable and talented. I don’t even think Gordon Ramsey cooks as good as you. Mill Creek, I will be back. Chef Aiden will go far.

Went to Mill Creek Inn for the Prime Rib. My Husband got the King cut and I got the Queen cut. My Husband remembered to take a picture of his meal about half way through and I completely forgot.
It was cooked perfectly for us (we both asked for medium rare). The meat was seasoned nicely and the au jus sauce was good and wasn't overwhelming salty.
I had broccoli spears with mine that were cooked perfectly.
Our server was named Shelly and although it was extremely busy she was great and kept our drinks full and got us out when we were ready to go.
The menu had some mouthwatering looking burgers and apps. I think we will be back to try a few out.

Such a cute little place. We enjoyed sitting on the outside patio for dinner. The food was quick and phenomenal. The service was also great!

Vegetarian pro tip: Order the California Burrito and skip the meat. My burrito was loaded with a delicious black bean corn salsa and sauce. Very tasty!

Tonight I had the Grill Cheese Brisket sandwich, with Onions rings. It's an amazing sandwich, Brisket isn't over cooked either. 😋 They need to bring back the Ribs though 😩. Don't pass this place up folks, great place to eat.

Great food, great service, and priced competitively. Best grilled cheese I have ever had in my life. Outdoor patio looks comfy.

Very good food, casual environment. And yes, it does get loud because it's a very popular joint that serves alcohol. If you can't handle noise, go on a weekday.

I visited here for the first time today and was shocked at the quantity of food for the money. Husband had the prime rib as it was a special. It was seasoned perfectly and it cut wonderfully. Mom got the bbq rib basket special and it fell off the bone beautifully. I had the Rueben and the in house corned beef was great. If I have any complaints it’s that I didn’t come hungrier.

Very quaint, very clean, and the food was fantastic.. drove an hour to have lunch with my girlfriend and it was with the trip.

Food is always amazing, and the waitresses are always on top of it! Anyone you talk to there is always super sweet and helpful. Very fun local watering hole 😉😁

Food and service was excellent. Friendly staff. They were super busy and food came out quickly. Definitely would come back.

Our server was great, prime rib was seasoned perfectly and was tender. Tiger shrimp was grilled and really great!

The best walleye fingers I've ever had in my life!! Nice thin coating and big fat pieces of walleye. Good tartar sauce and excellent fat nicely done fries Will definitely be back!😁

Birthday bloody Mary's were amazing!
First time I needed a to-go box for a drink!
Bloody mary drink was great and was served with a full tap beer of choice!

Best Ruben!! I won't get one anywhere else!!!

Had a good experience here for lunch with family! Food was great! Located along the lake, short walk to Buffalo Lake waterfront! Nice Patio for evenings!