Dustin's Pizzeria

Dustins is an asset to the community. Walking in is like being greeted by a long time friend and enjoying their company. The food is delicious and I would recommend the cheese pizza or the fish fry.
I have seen Dustin and his family around the community supporting all local businesses. This business and family are local and friendly. We have enjoyed them multiple times and will continue to do so.

Dustin's is the perfect small town pizza place. Great food, great service and fantastic owners. Dustin and Jenn now only run a great pizzaria, but they support our community every chance they get. And you won't find better pizza or wings anywhere in the area!

Hidden in a little knook in the town of Holley is Dustin's Pizzeria. They were steadily busy with takeouts while we waited for our pie, although there is plenty of room for dining in.
The sauce to cheese ratio complemented each other's flavor to perfection. The sauce tasted homemade and had hints of oregano and basil. I don't know if it is a homemade sauce recipe, as I did not ask, but it brought back memories of a New York City pizza we ate while exploring the Statue of Liberty. Yummmm.
Dustin's Pizzeria crust was neither too thick nor too thin, crispy on the bottom, and held up nicely to the thick cheese and pepperoni toppings.
We were surprised to find that both the flavor of the food and the price of it far exceeded the other guy that only sometimes treats you like family.
When we go again, we will dine in and eat that pizza as it was intended, hot out of the oven.

My family and I order from here a few times per month. Our main Staple is the sheet & 36 wings... but we have also tried just about everything else from their menu! Lol
The calzones are by far the BIGGEST Ive ever seen in my life!!! And are my kids favorites because they get to make it how they like and love being able to pick out the toppings.
The town of Holley doesn't have a big selection for ordering food.
(I believe 4-5 at most)
The places here are for "dine-in" or "pick-up" orders, so the ability to have orders delivered is a huge factor when it comes to where we order!
Give Dustin's a try, you won't be disappointed and are supporting a small town business as well!

This is our go to place when we order! We do pick up or have it delivered our food is always delicious. Staff are friendly, its clean just all around great atmosphere. Definitely recommend!! If you haven't tried their pickle pizza you are missing out!!

What a fantastic local pizza shop for our little town. The staff is always super friendly and the food makes my tummy happy! Their pizza is definitely my favorite around.

Very good service!! Steak grinder is absolutely awesome as is everything on the menu. Prices are very fair and the staff is friendly.I owned a pizzeria for 26 years so I’m very picky but I can say this place is very professional!! And my family always enjoys there food!!

Dustins sauce to their pizza is so good and the wings where big and nice with flavor keep up the small town work we love it and won’t anywhere else

Ordered pizza and country sweet wings last night for the family. It was delicious. The pizza was perfectly cooked and the wings were deliciously crispy!

My dad owned a pizzeria in Buffalo and his father before him. I know pizza. And if you're a fan of thick crust pizza as I am you'll find none better than Dustin's. The personnel are remarkably courteous as well. Well worth the drive to Holley.

We looooove Dustin's!! Best hometown pizza shop! Dustin and staff are always kind and quick! Food is always hot and fresh, and never disappoints! My family knows that if it's a quick dinner nite - we can always count on Dustin's to serve up everything on the menu at the best quality!

Tried Dustin's for the first time. I got pink sauce which was really good. A combination of white and red sauce. It was a thick crust. Nice and soft and cooked all the way through. Lots of toppings which is great. Tasted real good. It was nice to finally have real pizza unlike what my son and husband like to eat. Took normal amount of time. They offered limited amount of seating meeting social distancing rules but I took my meal to the falls across the street to eat. Will be back when in town.

Great home town pizzeria with good food, a big menu, and good customer service. They’re consistent, reputable and deserve your business.

Love the crust. Wings were excellent!!

Maybe it's just cause most enjoy their local pizzeria but Always like pizza here

We always have great food and service at Dustin’s!

Love, love, love dustins! The food is amazing, staff is always super friendly, and the prices are so fair.

Their pizza and garbage plates are the best around.

Never had anything I didn't like. Amazing food!

Always Delicious food and Amazing people that work there:)

Always yummy! I usually order delivery, the food is hot and delivered timely.
Also, their cheddar bacon fries are to die for 😍.