Lost Pizza Co. Madison

We loved the retro kind of atmosphere. They have lots of interesting wall mounted artifacts throughout the restaurant!! The menu is pretty diverse ranging from specialty pizzas, salads, wings, and includes a full bar. We shared a small salad. It didn’t look like the picture, but it was made with very fresh ingredients! The salad dressing appear to be homemade and delicious!

I had a small Otis on pan crust, my wife ordered a small Popeye. Both came out rather quickly. My wife loved hers and I really enjoyed mine. For me the crispness and flavor of the crust was exceptional. There’s also something to be said for the texture and stringiness of the cheeses used in the pizzas. We both left with half of our pizzas for the next day. It was a great meal and we will definitely return to try different menu items.

If you are a child of the '70s, you will enjoy the decor! Make sure you bring your children and grandchildren so that you can bore, I mean entertain, them with all of your stories relating to the memorabilia on the walls. As for the food, it is delicious and plentiful. We ordered pizza, sandwiches, and the dessert cookie. And also the angel hair and meatballs, which I forgot to take a picture of before I ate it all. It really was too much but also just perfect for Sunday lunch. There's a lot of seating, a big main room plus a smaller side room. You order up at the counter and they bring the food to your table. It is nice to have another good sit-down pizza place in town!

We did an online pickup order. Food was ready quickly and before it was promised. Food was hot even when we arrived home with it. The mild wings are CRAZY spicy.. the Caesar salad was so good, best I've ever had.. I don't know if the dressing is house made or not but it was lick the bowl clean good. The garlic bread was good and so was the dipping sauce.. Again I'm thinking house made, yummy.. Let's not forget about the pizza.. it was exceptional.. it not only looked good it tasted good.. the toppings where good sized and not overbearing... It wasn't greasy and the toppings didn't fall off..great food good service we will be back. I gotta try the fried ravioli.

Great experience for our family's 1st trip to Lost Pizza Co.! Orders are taken at the counter and the menu has a wide variety of options. The staff was helpful with any questions we had. The food was brought out very quickly and our order was correct. We enjoyed all of our dishes and look forward to trying more on the menu!

The 80s theme was very neat. We had garlic bread and a large pizza. I liked the smaller pieces of crunchy garlic bread. We should have gotten a medium pizza, but it was nice to have leftovers the next morning. I've driven by this place tons and never noticed it.

Thin crust Pizza/spaghetti and salad 👍🏻👍🏻. Atmosphere ❤

I'm a huge fan of pizza. I'm always looking for that next amazing slice! ~ NEXT DAY COLD, you can eat the pizza right out of the fridge and it's got good flavors, it's delicious!! I LIKE THAT !!!!

Kid friendly with booster chairs, menu

We’ve been waiting for Lost Pizza Co. to open in Madison! And we were not disappointed!! We were greeted by friendly and super helpful staff. Food came out quickly and the pizza was fantastic!! Lots of toppings and lots of options! We’ll be back very soon.

Very cool atmosphere with all the vintage decor and the pizza was excellent! The restaurant may look small on the outside but there is actually quite a bit of seating so go on in & check it out!

I’ve never heard of this pizza company. That was very excited for a restaurant that was within walking distance of our home! And the kids begged for us to eat here tonight, so we decided to give it a shot!
Since it just opened, it was busy and we went during peak time, but the weight was not extremely long and the service was great !

I’m very excited to say that this is now our only place for pizza because it was just that good compared to anything else in the area !

I love the atmosphere and the music… 10/10 would recommend!

We stumbled upon this very cool restaurant while out shopping and decided to give it a shot. We are exceptionally glad that we did! The atmosphere is very cool. The service was good, and the food was absolutely fantastic. I don't have anything negative to say whatsoever. The one thing that we did learn, was that my husband needs to order a medium pizza next time instead of a small. The small was more than enough for me but it wasn't quite enough for him. We will absolutely be back! Highly recommend!

The cheesy bread is perfect! (labeled as cheese sticks on the menu) We weren’t the biggest fans of the texture of the thick crust pizza, but it has flawless flavor—we will come back to try the thin!

This is by far the BEST Pizza that I have ever eaten. The flavor, the crust; everything is cooked to perfection! The crust is not dry hard crust; it’s a buttery crispy texture that tastes musty; must have more. I will only eat pizza from The Lost Pizza Co. I highly recommend everyone to try this pizza place. Every piece had the same amount of toppings and the sauce had so much flavor and it tasted so amazingly delicious! It was so fresh and I wanted to keep on eating the pizza even after I was full because it tasted so delicious!!
You can taste so many seasonings and the sauce tasted so delicious.

Beekeeper pizza was delicious. Small size was perfect for me for lunch. Just the right size. Staff was very friendly also.

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Lost Pizza, and I must say, it was an exceptional experience from start to finish.

The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with a cozy ambiance that makes you feel right at home. The staff is incredibly friendly and attentive, ensuring that every guest feels welcomed and well taken care of.

Now, onto the star of the show – the pizza! The menu offers a fantastic variety of options. I opted for the pepperoni pizza, and it did not disappoint. Each bite was a delightful explosion of taste.

In addition to their amazing pizzas, they also offer a great selection of appetizers, and desserts. The chicken wings are a must-try – they are fresh, and packed with flavor.

Overall, Lost Pizza delivers on all fronts – delicious food, excellent service, and a great atmosphere. Whether you’re looking for a casual dinner with friends or a special night out, this place is a fantastic choice. I highly recommend giving it a try!

We all love this place. My husband really likes the pizza with honey in the crust. I'm not sure of the name of it, I love the pepperoni pizza with pesto on top. If you're ordering online, make sure you ask for the pesto on top. If not, that'll be your sauce. You will have no red sauce.
The Olive Bread is awesome. I don't particularly like the crunchy (I think it's carrots) on the top. Next time, I'll order it without that. Other than that, it's the best!

Good pizza with unique choice options. Additional they have sandwiches apps and wings nice gem right in the middle of Madison AL

The small pizzas are perfect for a single person. We wanted to be able to try different things since it was our first time here. I have tried the regular and the thin crust and liked both. I don't normally like thin crust but it was just thick enough to support the toppings which is a big deal for me. The staff are really nice and do a great job as well.

There is a location back in my hometown that friends and family always talk about-so I was interested in giving Lost Pizza a try. It was amazing! We had the olive bread, a thick crust pizza, thin crust pizza, and a meatball sub. Everybody in the party was extremely happy! Quick service and very reasonable prices! We will DEFINITELY be coming back (I hope next weekend!)!

The restaurant was busy, as it was 6pm. We were able to make it through the ordering line pretty quickly. Ordered cheese sticks, side salad, large Kujo pizza, and the meatball sandwich. The side salad came out almost immediately, by a very sweet young lady. It was well prepared with the right amount of toppings. The ranch dressing was absolutely perfect. Had to buy a bottle to take home! All food was delivered in a reasonable amount of time. Hot fresh and tasted absolutely delicious. I will definitely be back to try more options. The only negative was the dining room being a little small and seat yourself.

We have been eating Lost Pizza for years and we were so excited when they announced this location. The pizzas are amazing, the crust has just the right amount of crunch and chewiness. The pastas are also delicious. We've never been disappointed with any of their food. The staff were fantastic and super friendly. Look forward to coming back soon.