Pizza Madness Maui

Amazing pizza, amazing staff and a welcoming atmosphere! Our pizza had tons of cheese and pepperoni on it and just the though of how good the pizza tasted is making my mouth water....so glad there are leftovers for a midnight snack lol

The pizza was outstanding. Wings need improvement. Typical atmosphere. Great service.

Drink selections were pretty decent. The wife had wine, and I had a local craft beer. I had wings and shared a 10-inch pizza with my wife. We had 3 slices left over. She says among the best pizzas she's ever had.

The wings were good, but I don't like the way they did them. They were basically fried chicken with your ordered sauce on the side. I ordered the hot wings. The sauce was simply Frank's hot sauce or some varient of it. When I order wings, I expect the sauce to be different from other hot wings, as in this chef putting his signature into it. Using the same simple sauce as everyone else degrades the experience. Also, I'd prefer tossed wings than just having sauce on the side. I poured the sauce on my wings, and it was not near enough, only partly covering one side of the wings. I asked for more sauce and was quickly accommodated. Besides the sauce, the fried chicken wings were really good, cooked perfect with the perfect amount of crisp on the outside.

The atmosphere was pretty typical for a place like this. Good, but I also didn't see anything that made them stand out. One worth mention is that all their TVs are on one side of the dining area. If you're facing the doors, you can't see a single TV, see pictures.

Overall, I do recommend stopping in and getting full.

Delicious pizza! A little expensive but worth it. Service was good. The atmosphere was OK.

The best pizza on Maui! My entire family has been eating only pizza madness pizza for a while now. We had to get pizza from elsewhere recently…and it didn’t compare. No where near close. My daughter is very picky. She will eat pizza madness food, but not very many other places. Highly recommend!

Went here in 2010. Bought the T-Shirt because it was the best pizza I’d ever consumed. Now 14 years later, we went back. Bought another T-Shirt and I still believe this is the best I’ve ever had and certainly the best on the island. Sad to hear about the owners passing but very happy that his legacy lives on with the current owners/employees 😎 If you’re in Kehei don’t miss an opportunity to enjoy some fine food, drink and hospitality.

We ordered a veggie pizza and it tasted amazing. We also ordered a garlic bread and that was good too. The service was quick and the vibe was good. It’s mainly for pizza with a drink but we enjoyed our time there. One thing we liked the most was that the pizza had lot of veggies, not a lot of veggie pizzas have them so we liked that it had lots of veggies. A 10 slice was enough for 2 ppl but we thought it was a bit expensive for the size.

This is by far some of the best pizza I have ever had! have tried quite a few types and places over my life and I can makes it in the top 3 places.

I highly recommend you go here for pizza! The atmosphere is great, the service is great, the food is great! The facilities were also great!

I tried different pizzas and their chicken wings! Both were epic and cooked perfectly! The wings, you will find are also some of the best you'll ever find! The way they are cooked simply is unique and just amazing!

You just can't go wrong.

They offer take out as well. While we were there the tables were full, but people rotated out just enough so you could seat yourself.

They also have seating at the bar which primarily serves beer, but does offer a few spirits to choose from.

They are clearly popular as the take out line was constantly on the go! What surprised me though was how efficiently this place ran despite the volume that was being put through this restaurant.

***The only thing I would change is the napkins. If I could rate half stars on here, I would give. 4.5 stars. I'm not sure why so many restaurants choose to use cheep napkins especially when the food served is to be eaten with your fingers. The napkins simplu fall apart after one basic use and feel like they will desolve. I personally had to use a stack about 1 inch thick for one meal!

Other than that, well done Pizza Madness Maui!

Omg such a nice place! The atmosphere is nice but the service was amazing! Like seriously the sweetest person. We loved the food and drinks and desserts, so yes everything. Very chill and good with the kids. Their sandwiches looks very yummy too, I think we’ll have to go back before leaving Maui!

Very lively place with good pizza. It can get crowded but it was one of three games places on the island we found where locals would go too.

We had the large special pizza, between the two of us only managed to eat half of it and ate the rest on our trip to the top of the island next day. Very tasty even cold and very filling, local beers on tap.

Service was super quick and friendly.

The 🍕 related artwoek on the walls is cool especially the fish centerpiece in my opinion.

Great food and the prices were reasonable. Friendly staff and atmosphere. We found our new pizza spot in Maui

We loved the pizza! The ingredients were all very fresh and flavorful, as well as the sauce!

Dropped in here after a few other spots were slammed—we got a table right away, and knew it was going to be good—mostly a local crowd, and it had that 1990’s pizzeria vibe. Hot wings, a side salad and pepperoni pizza hit the spot. A great way to end the day, and a pleasant surprise! Give it a try, you won’t be disappointed!

Everyone visiting Kihei should know about this place! Food is delicious, ambience is super cool and the people are super friendly!! Dine local and help the people from Maui recover! This place deserves all the stars and the good reviews.
I hope to come back some time. Mahalo!

Great place for "chicago style" pizza. Pizza was very good, crust was delicious. Service was prompt and servers friendly. Anyone from Chicago area will definitely appreciate!

For my first night back on Maui, this was the perfect spot to get something to eat for dinner. Food was picture perfect but I didn't take any pics because it was consumed too quickly. Beer selection was appropriate and diverse for everyone's taste.

This place was a great find! We found it purely from only me reviews - and so glad we did. It is a small joint, but very good service and food. My wife and I split a pepperoni pizza, and I got a side of the wings. Some of the most crispy wings I've ever had! The staff was very friendly, and we got our food quickly. I highly recommend you try this place out!

So I’m very gluten sensitive, and I was very very skeptical about ordering a gluten free pizza, from a pizzeria, much less a gluten free pizza from a restaurant, but I took the chance of ordering from PIZZA MADNESS, and this part I’m totally screaming, OMG, PIZZA MADNESS IS ONE OF THE BEST PLACES I’VE HAD A GLUTEN FREE PIZZA FORM ANYWHERE, MAY IT BE MAINLAND USA, HONOLULU, or MAUI, MY GOSH THE DOE WAS PERFECT, and I ASKED FOR EXTRA CRIPSY and that is what I got, not soggy crispy, but firm crispy, the sauce was well seasoned and the ingredients were fresh, that is what I loved about it, the one that’s on the left is gluten free and the pizza on the right is the regular pizza, and my husband absolutely loved it from the moment he tasted it at Pizza Madness. 20 STARS OUT OF 5 STARS.

Wanted something simple and quick to take back to the condo for the evening. We called ahead and they had our pizza ready in 30 minutes. The place looked inviting and staff was friendly when picking up. We ordered the sausage and mushrooms pizza and it was perfect. The crust was crispy and doughy and cooked perfectly. Being from Wisconsin We like our cheese and they had the perfect amount along with the sauce that was spiced just right. So far they have been the best pizza in Hawaii we have tasted. Total price was about $22. Hope this was helpful.

The pizza was amazing, the service was fantastic and the price was reasonable. The only issue is, we are heading back to the States tomorrow and didn’t find this place until our last night on the island.

Great pizza and great service. We came in late on a Monday night. The pizza was fantastic and the staff was extremely friendly. We will definitely be back again!