Sweet Pea's

I did not try their food, but I was researching for a class project and they made it easy to talk with them and were very supportive and helpful.
1. She also had some super helpful tips and was a huge encouragement and really made a difference for me and my project. I hope I can be as helpful and supportive if I ever I own a business someday.
2. I would also recommend their services highly to others.

We don't live in Mayville, but we will make the trip over for Sweet Pea's! We love their gluten free options. We love that we can special order something. We got an ice cream pie yesterday. It was a peanut butter and cookie dough combination. It was pretty dang awesome!

We met the owner and we got to see her dog, she js very nice and the food it amazing

I had a hankering for key lime pie while camping in Horicon and found Sweet Pea's. Wow, the pies were delicious. We have eaten a lot of key lime pie because we go to the keys every year and this was one of the best we have ever had (even without the key limes 😃). We also had the peanut butter chocolate pie and it was delicious. Not too sweet and just creamy and perfect. Make sure to stop in, you will not be disappointed.

I was in town to drop off my granddaughter, I brought my grandsons to get ice cream. I never expected to find such a jewel. To me, Sweet Peas feels like an actual ice cream shoppe. There were so many choices it made it difficult to pick just 2 flavors. The waffle cones and ice cream were delicious. The service was warm and friendly. After ordering I noticed they had single serving tarts, pie slices, and cheesecakes! Yesterday I called to order 2 dozen chocolate chips cookies for a party and I pick them up today The lady over the phone was so very helpful and accommodating. I am so excited to share this wonderful shop with my family.

Got some pie and ice cream last week when the owner opened up outside. Had a slice of cherry crumble and a strawberry and peach pie. So good!

Amazing little shop, I'm new here in Mayville and I took my 2 son's with me to try some ice cream today, all 3 of us absolutely loved the ice cream and the cones, my sons loved the sprinkles that you added for them. Definitely can't wait to come back and try everything over time, and I can't forget how nice you are as well, that is the cherry on top for you all. Thanks for the wonderful experience and I cant wait to return!!!!

The owner went out of her way to make our visit very special. Went there on my wife's birthday and after she found out that I was hunting for a cheesecake, she didn't hesitate to make that happen right away and very convenient for us even tho it prolly wasn't the most convenient for them. And it was delicious!

Your cakes & pies are awesome! Thank you so very much for you excellent customer service!! You saved me with a German Chocolate Cake that was to "die for" and with less than 24 hours notice! You are a life saver & we are customers for life! Thank you again & may you and your family have a blessed year!

-Ryan

Great customer service! Always love the atmosphere here. Probably one of Mayvilles best shops.

Had a chance to work with the owners on a renovation project. Had a few opportunities to sample some of the ice cream and pies. The honey pie is simply amazing, try it warmed up with a bit of ice cream. Overall it was a delicious and delightful experience. I look forward to going back.

So good! I am only disappointed that I didn’t get a full size key lime pie. Haven’t had one so good since I was in Key West FL. Great little place, I was looking for a coffee shop that must’ve been the previous business, to get some treats and coffee but this was even better. Will definitely be back for that full size key lime pie next time we’re in the area!

Love this new business and bakery in Mayville! Our boys enjoy the ice cream, and I love their individual slices or whole pies. I splurged on the chocolate cake with strawberry frosting and it was amazing! Stop by and enjoy their sweet treats! Yum!

Best place to go for pies or shake of the month. Definitely me and my sons favorite place in town (:

Stopped by with the kids today after swimming at TAG. We got some excellent ice cream and a slice of cherry crumble pie. Everyone was friendly and the place is nice. We'll definitely be back.

After 3 visits I haven't had a single bad experience. The pies are incredible! The filling...the crust...all scrumptious. I highly recommend the honey pie. It may sound strange if you haven't tried it before but it's so good.

Hands down best ice cream I have had in Wisconsin. Super friendly staff absolutely love this place and will come back.

Great cherry pie with vanilla ice cream

Quaint shop that is a must stop in Mayville. Blueberry pie was delicious! Several pie options, and great selection of ice cream with homemade waffle cones!

Some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had. Great vibes, and beautiful downtown area. Raspberry Lemon bar ice cream was excellent!