Casey's

I made a mistake when I ordered my pizza online. Then decided to take care of it when I went into the store. Tristan was able to correct my mistake and helped me out so much and made this a much more pleasant experience!!

We were in Baldwin City visiting for 4 days and I went to this Casey's about 5 times for coffee/donut/soda/gas and what not. Each visit was just as it should have been. The staff were friendly and welcoming.

They. Were. SLAMMED. I was in around 1pm today with my husband, and they did great seeing as how everybody and their mother was there with us.
For being a brand new store, as in just opened yesterday, they're doing fantastic! The other people complaining are fussing about things Casey's can't control. Get over yourselves, peeps. It's a gas station.

I love Casey's pizza! Try the bbq! Also, they have cheap soft drinks and near-beer!

What a fine establishment. Went for the grand opening and had a lovely experience. Breakfast pizza and donuts smack at 5:30 in the morning😋

Casey's is always AWESOME!! Don't listen to the haters. 👍

I just had the BEST pizzas ever from Caseys!!!!! I mean soooooo good. Thank you Brandon for making such great pizzas. I'm gonna make sure you are working the kitchen whenever I order again.

Very nice store and much bigger than the old store.

I love this place and I am so happy we have one close by, but there really needs to be a more reliable way to order food. I couldn't order online so I tried to call, which had worked in the past. But now the phone isn't working either. I tried to let the man behind the counter (tall guy black hair) know that the line was not working but he seemed to be more involved in putting change in the drawer than to actually listen to me.

Like I said, I love the food, but please, please make it easier to get it!

Pizza is not the same and apple fritters are horrible

Their is no warmers ready, cooler is never stocked, lack of cashiers, trash is overflowing, and service is poor and the bathrooms are disgusting. This place needs work and new mangement could be used.

Hours online say they open at 5AM. I came by at 620AM and they were closed. Fix your hours on Google Maps!

If there are more than 2 people in line prepare to wait. Cashiers are crazy slow and want to make 5 minutes of small talk with each customer after ringing them up. Some of us just want to pay and be on our way.

Caseys you need to figure out your checkout process. QT has is down. Since they're your direct competition maybe you should try to keep up.

Pointed out to cashier that we were clearly overcharged (according to sign on product) and was told I have to come back when manager is available. Was also charged for dipping sauce with hot food item that he refused to reimburse because he said "most people don't dip sandwiches". The $6.49 I paid for a dried out Hawaiian bbq brisket sandwich was a total waste of money - may have been better if it had some sauce on it. I live 20 miles from this store. How am I supposed to get money back? This store won't be one I patronize again anytime soon.

I would like to buy gas here on my way to and from work. But go 20 minutes west or 12 minutes NW or SW and save every time. Been that way for months. Come on and match the numbers with in 20 mile radius.