Pagliai's Grinnell

If you love a thin, very crispy crust pizza... this is the place for you! We had the shrimp alfredo pizza, and it was magnificent! I wanted to try that champagne cake, but there's was no room left after we polished off that pizza! Next time! The staff are friendly, the service is great, and the food doesn't disappoint one bit! They open daily at 5pm. Open until 9pm Sun-Thurs, and open until 10pm Fri-Sat. Enjoy!

This place is the best!!! The Meatballs are a must do appetizer. The meatballs are cooked perfectly and the sauce, well it gets 10 stars! The pizzas and Lasagna are also super great! The house special Champaign cake is a nice touch to finish off your meal. This place will not disappoint you if you love Italian food. Hands done one of the best kept secrets in eastern Iowa.

Awesome flavor. Meatballs and cheese bread is an excellent combo. Pizza is great. Awesome staff and atmosphere. Thanks!

The pizza is is fresh, hot, and delicious! The wait was a bit long but it was (rightly) very busy. Definitely worth it! We enjoyed the Bruschetta, Pepperoni Pesto pizza, Shrimp Alfredo pizza, and Char's Champagne Cake.

I grew up near here and had not been to this location in over 20 years. Nothing has changed since then, not even the seating. It's still the best pizza I have ever had!

WOW! Delicious, fresh, handmade food, excellent service, inviting ambiance, & affordable prices! Some of the best thin crust pizza I’ve had & it was served piping hot! The house made sausage is amazing. The pag hero was piled so high, it was hard to take a bite out of it. The bruschetta was yummy. Ranch dressing was also tasty. Loved this place & will return next time we’re in town!

It was my first time there and I enjoyed it. Sarah was fantastic. The pizza was great. The cheese bread came out hot and was so good. I recommend this place to everyone 👌

Our church group met here with 6 couples for pizza & fellowship. The service was friendly & efficent. The pizza was the best I have had in a long time.

I tried the steak sandwich. It was the best toasted sandwich I have ever tasted. So wonderful to know you can have pasta, pizza or a sandwich. Bravo!

They live up to their reputation as Iowa's best pizza. Interesting Iowa beers. Best server we have had in a long time - Jessica! Definitely coming back when in area. Worth the stop. Nice town as well.

Always great pizza, fun to watch them make the pizzas. Great, genuine service. Large and small spaces available but cozy enough for conversations.

I’m from NY and have never had such an amazing pizza! Thin crust was perfect, the toppings were delicious and generous, and the vibe was excellent. Great restaurant for families, dates, or having a bite with friends. Kudos to the chef and cooking staff as well as the servers. Excellent experience! Highly recommend when in Grinnell.

I have never tasted better pizza,we got are food right away 🩷🩷🩷it is so clean and the bread sticks were delicious 😋

Have been here numerous times, always wonderful! Had a reservation for a party of 60 ppl and they did great!

Pizza and service was excellent! Pictured is a sausage and mushroom pizza cut into squares! Wednesdays special is a medium 2 topping for $11 .. regular price is $16.50..nice savings!

Love the food and the atmosphere here! Taco pizza is delicious, I like the sour cream actually on the pizza instead of a side and the shredded cheddar is piled high.

We ordered a taco pizza and a pagliai's special. Fresh ingredients, crisp crust right amount of sauce and was still hot when we got home . (12 miles)👍

Amazing Service .This is my first time ever here and I'm impressed!! What even more amazing is how even if it busy and they still make sure that you are taken care of.The Pizza looks awesome they ask if your service was good and it family friendly and group friendly if you have a group or family event they even have frozen pizza's. There is also wine if you like it there is pasta as well .I can't wait to come back to try the pasta. It was worth the drive

Amazing food and owners. Doesn’t disappoint.

Quite a bit of space on the inside actually, and you get to see them making the pizzas while you're waiting. They have great appetizers for amazing prices, their pizza is phenomenal, gotta get it with a bottle of ranch too. My favorite pizza they have had was a limited time Pickle Pizza