Game Time

First time at this place. I bought a bunch of their $10 bulk boxes of commons/uncommons. I was curious what the breakdown of cards inside was like so I counted:

Average around 400-450 cards, no basic mana, a little non-basic land. ~100 unique cards per bulk pack (so still decent number of duplicates BUT the highest # of dups for one card was 12 with an average of 3-4 dups per card... not bad at all imo. ~13% of the packs were uncommons.

They're all separated by set, which is nice if you're trying to fill out a collection. I've had some bad experiences in the past with grab boxes having like... 50 duplicates of multiple cards. Not the case with Game Time's boxes.

For 10 bucks, these grab boxes are really well-made. Its obvious going through the cards that they had been sorted and an attempt was made to be fair and equal (no chunks of all blue or white cards.) Very evenly distributed across the colors.

I think these boxes are EXCELLENT for younger players who need a good variety of cards without breaking the bank. Its not like the deal of the century or anything, considering you're getting mostly commons but the variety and even distribution of cards across all colors makes me believe the guys that packed this box were not just using them as a worthless dump of commons. They actually put time and effort into making these boxes worth every dollar. (See photos for even distribution of colors. The stacks at the bottom of the the photos are the unique cards with the larger stacks behind them are the duplicates.)

The employees seemed friendly and knowledgeable too.

I didn’t have a problem here. Thought some of the cards were overpriced, but that’s the name of the game I guess.

The workers were cool and I picked up some cool cards. Will likely come back

Update: have been going to this store for months and it’s become my favorite TCG store in the area. Great singles selection and really cool workers. Still think some of the boxes are overpriced but eh, that’s alright.

Magic players rejoice! I have never seen such a diverse collection of booster boxes in one place before. Perfect for chaos drafts or if you're looking for a particular older set. Plenty of singles to browse through as well. Aside from that, the store is very clean and well organized. Plenty of other TCGs, tabletop RPGs, and board games. The only thing I could ask for is a larger board game selection, but their focus is obviously geared toward the TCGs. Would definitely love to come in for a tournament one night. The staff was also friendly and extremely knowledgeable.

I love this place because I had the best experience there when I wanted to buy magic cards and they had a better selection than moonshot

This is one of my favorite game store for Magic: The Gathering and the occasional army painter accessories for my miniature painting. All the employees are cool and never make you feel like they are judging you with a sense of superiority. And the prices are reasonable. Plus the rewards program can't be beat.

Went in with my son, since he has mastered basic board games like monopoly and life and all. I asked the staff member for a recommendation and he took alot of time telling us about various games until we found one WE LOVE!!!! And they have a great selection of Pokemon cards, which my son LOVED! I'll be going back for sure!

Great store. Great selection! I brought my two young kids in to play Pokémon TCG and were able to get a few rounds in with some other folks.

If you plan on bringing any cards in to exchange for store credit, I highly suggest looking at their schedule. If there is a tournament or open play going on, the store gets much busier and service takes understandably longer. We’ve always gotten fair prices and we love the selection that they have!

Very friendly staff AND there are demo games! How cool is that?!?! I've been in board game stores that have this feature and some that don't. This makes a board game store great! I want to try games before purchasing and they let you do this here. They also have Magic and Pokemon cards. A separate room for fame playing. And the store is family friendly. I will be back!

Went to sell my Pokemon Card collection. I believe I got a reasonable price for my collection. $10 per 1000 of common cards and then a bunch of rares I sold netted me $65 of store credit. I know I could have gotten more if I sold them online myself, but I like supporting local game stores. The staff was fast, store was very clean and spacious. Big room in the back for gaming. I would like to visit again.

I come to this place for mostly Magic cards, and in that regard, they definitely have the most extensive selection I’ve seen in town. In addition to that, the staff were all patient and helpful with me. I’m a relatively new Magic player, and they took the time to explain my options - to make sure I knew exactly what I was buying and that it was something I wanted. Great place.

A great shop that works primarily with Magic the gathering but offers a broad range of games for nerds of all ages.

One of the largest game stores in the area for magic the gathering. They also deal in boardgames and table top. Their competitive trading card game scene is pretty good, offering events throughout the week with good prize support. They purchase cards at a fair rate and sell pretty much everything you'd want except maybe some really obscure things. Can easily recommend for your gaming needs

This is easily one of the best board and card game stores in the city. The staff is nice and incredibly helpful. The prices are very fair. The selection has nearly everything you could need (and if they don't have it, they'll gladly order it for you). They have a free rewards program which gives you a $10 discount for every $100 spent (which we all know isn't too difficult with gaming). The store itself has a large gaming area open for use with dozens of tables, hosting different types of events throughout the week.
Game Time 10/10

Beautiful game store with a vast selection of Magic: the Gathering singles. Easily one of the #1 places to play competitive Magic in the state. Turnout for events is huge and there are different fotmats running daily. Prize support is solid. Legacy, Commander, Modern, and Standard are all regularly represented. The community is full of tiered meta decks that should give you a good idea of your deck's performance in other regional events. If you are serious about your Magic play there is no reason not to visit.

As a reflection of the brick and mortar era, this place stands out as an example of the customer service and value that is sorely missing. Every visit to the store is a treat. My kids are treated just as friendly and professionally as I am. Their selection is vast, and the fact that I can try some games beforehand is a real bonus. Can not recommend high enough.

Took my son to learn to play Pokémon. The staff and volunteers were great. Half the shop was retail half was table for play. He had a great time. They had a wide selection of board games and competitive prices.

Super friendly staff. I'm not a gamer, but my wife is, and they took their time helping me find a number of items for her as gifts. Would definitely go back. They have a decently sized area for in house gaming, if that's your thing.

I have been doing business with this place for multiple years. Jeremy the owner is an amazing guy. The staff is wonderful. It takes sometime to process card list request, but that's expected with how busy they are. Thank you for a consistent experience! I will always recommend your store.

I could not be happier with my experiences at this store. They gave me good value when I sold my Magic collection. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. I cannot recommend this store enough.

One of the best game stores in Indy. Great selection, accomodating staff. A large open play area recently added. One of the few places around selling Pokemon single cards.