High, Wide, & Handsome PIZZARIA

Wonderful little place! The Garlic Swirls with Spinach and Artichoke were delicious. The pizza had great flavor, lots of toppings, not greasy (we had The Deluxe), service was friendly, couldn't ask for more! Will definitely go back!

I'm visiting from Virginia and I saw this place listed in a local magazine. My boyfriend and I decided to try it out and wow, we were both blown away!!! The popper spirals were absolutely delicious! And the two of us got three 7 in pizzas to share. The Buffalo Chicken, the Viking, and the Old Milwaukee--all three very different and all three amazing in their own way. I am debating going in and trying some of the others tomorrow for lunch! That's how much I loved it! Their local beer selection on tap was also on point! Very different styles to accommodate all tastes. Can't wait until the next time!!!

Such a good experience! We loved the pizza: great sauce, cheese, outstanding bacon, crust, and range of ingredients. I wanted to limit lactose, so went with just goat cheese (and pineapple and bacon) on my pizza; they were super conscientious and made sure to let me know about the milk in the crust; not only is their pizza awesome, their customer care is above-and-beyond. We will definitely be back!

We had the opportunity to visit the new Decorah location on "Training Day". The inside looks nice and the atmosphere is great, with a small bar and beer on tap. The employees are friendly, and the pizza was delicious. We ordered a bacon cheeseburger pizza and can't wait to try others.

Great pizza place in Decorah. Have been several times in the past and this time was excellent too. Had the Sicilian pizza amd really enjoyed it. The whole roasted garlic cloves make the pizza. If you have never had roasted garlic, you should try this pizza. The meat, cheese, sauce, and peppers are all fantastic but the garlic brings it all home without being overpowering. The crust, which normally I don't care about enough to talk about, is fantastic. We normally get their garlic knots but didn't this time...I had to keep room for Ice Cream at the Sugar Bowl up the street.

The best pizza in Northeast Iowa hands down. The owner (Jason, I believe) and all of his help are great and friendly as they come. The toppings on the pizza are so hearty and flavorful. One of my favorite pizza's is the Buffalo Chicken and I've added a photo. Do yourself a favor and enjoy one their pizza's.

We came from La Crosse for the day and were searching for restaurants in the area. Unfortunately, this one did not come up on our searches, but after recommendations from a couple locals we decided to stop here. We are SO glad we did! The menu has a good variety of recipes and bar drinks. We had the spinach and artichoke spirals for an appetizer and they were fantastic! We each had individual pizzas- margherita pizza and Mediterranean pizza, both were amazing! The service was great from Mr. HWH himself! We will definitely recommend to friends that visit Decorah and we’ll be back ourselves.

Been there twice, ordered the Deluxe. They are doing everything right. High quality ingredients, perfect crust, not too thick or thin, and a really nice sauce. They go light on the sauce but it has a really complex, great flavor, you don't need that much.

This is my #1 pizza place, and I've traveled all over. They've really got a good thing going here.

Our first visit to High, Wide and Handsome in their new restaraunt and We were impressed. Our party had individual pizzas and garlic swirls. The waitstaff were friendly and efficient. The atmosphere was pleasant and clean . The food was awesome! Would highly recommend to others. Thanks for bringing a great new pizza option to town !

I've had the Three Little Pigs, the Big Kahuna and the Viking- ALL were fabulous!!! The flavor combinations are well thought out and the crust is perfect! Not too thin, not too thick and enjoying those last bites of the end of the pizza crust finish it off perfectly. The atmosphere is great- very clean (even the restrooms!) mellow music, and beautiful decor. While the wait staff appear young, they appear to be doing a great job fulfilling the diner's needs. I will be back frequently!

I love this place! Was just passing through town and stopped downtown to find something to eat on Saturday night, tried two other restaurants that both had a longer wait than what we could manage. Ended up going to High, Wide and Handsome pizza because it didn't look very busy. I was blown away by the first rate service, the top notch food, and the cool atmosphere of the place. I don't understand why people weren't lined up outside the door.

So many pizza flavors! Unbelievable! The Mediterranean was amazing; the lamb was succulent, the olives briny and the feta salty deliciousness! The chicken Alfredo pizza has tender juicy chicken with a luscious sauce! EAT HERE!!

What sets this place apart is it's unique selection of specialty pizzas. We had a Big Hahuna and a Three Little Pigs which were both great. The building has been updated since the previous owner and looks great. They also have a good selection of beer at fair prices.

We knew as soon as we walked in we were going to love this pizza !! Great homemade chewy crust, creamy cheese and robust sauce. 5 of 5 without a doubt. Get get yourself some- you won’t be disappointed.

A few friends and I traveled to Decorah from Wisconsin and we looking for somewhere to eat. We found High, Wide, and Handsome Pizza and were very pleased with this place! Pizza was very very good! The garlic swirls were absolutely amazing! Very convenient to order at the bar and find your own seat. I always feel like this is a more efficient way to do pizza vs waiting to be seated, then waiting for server to order dinks, then wait for drinks, then order food, then wait for food, then wait for bilI, then wait for them to pick up bill, then wait for change. Applaud the risk of efficiency instead of traditional serving. If you are in the beautiful little City of Decorah, you definitely need to try this place. You will not be disappointed.

First time to sample this pizza last night and, bar none, this is the BEST PIZZA in our NE Iowa area. Ordered the pizza and then went to the PIVO craft beer tasting room and they delivered the pizza there. Really, can't say enough about the quality of the pizza. Crust not to thin, not to thick and the toppings are so, so good. Go there!

Ok so, I was told in Decorah you have to try Mabes Pizza. Since I love a good pie I was going to take up the challenge. One thing got in my way. High Wide and Handsome. This maybe the best Pizza I have ever eaten. So try High Wide and Handsome the new place to get pizza in Decorah!

SO SO GOOD!!! Kahuna & Deluxe- lots of toppings. Highly recommend.

Delicious pizza! They have very unique flavors that just blend together so well. Friendly staff and owners. Quaint little pizzeria.

Fun place to hang out. Pizza was very good. Garlic rolls were very fun. Overall a nice new pizza place for Decorah. We will be back!