Papa's Pizza Oven

Great tastings pizza and wings at an affordable price! The pizza is crisp and not greasy with lots of cheese, great sauce ( we like the regular style not sweet) and crisp pepperoni. We like that it is cut with different size slices actually! Wings and also crisp and delicious! Highly recommend

As a native Long Islander, I am very particular about my pizza. I’ve never been a huge fan of Buffalo-style pizza…that was until I found Papa’s Pizza Oven. Finding this family-owned pizza place was like a breath of fresh air in a sea of unfortunate pizza experiences i’ve had in Buffalo. The first time I walked into Papa’s, I was adorably greeted by the owner’s 9 year old son. It’s no question where he gets his charisma from—the owner welcomed me with a kindness that made me feel right at home.

This place is OUTSTANDING. Hands down the best pizza in all of Buffalo. Their sweet sauce is unlike anything i’ve ever had before—absolutely delicious!! After my first visit to Papa’s, I found myself going back a few short days later, unable to shake the thought of their savory slices.

Now onto the wings!! They are everything you could possibly want in a wing. Big, saucy & crunchy. The garlic sticks are phenomenal as well. Light, airy & full of flavor. Needless to say, i’m counting down the days until I am back in Buffalo so I can visit Papa’s once again!

The pizza is the best in lancaster. It's so good I tossed all the other pizzeria menus in trash and only order from papas

Heard about this place from DJ Anthony (Kiss 98.5) DJ.

He posted several times and the pizza looked good, so I had to try it!

I do not regret this b/c the pizza was delicious! I tried it with the regular sauce. Came back a couple days later and brought a half ch & pepperoni & 10 hot barbecue wings.

The wings were big and delicious as well, so now that’s my new go to place!

The Sweet Sauce is Amazing! Tastes like the old Wise Guys on Seneca St. Super tasty. They are a bit on the pricy side tho. All we ordered a was LG Cheese and Pep and it was close to $30 which is kinda crazy for just a pie. I remember getting a Large Pie for $10. I Could understand Chicken Wings being high but even those have come down in price. I can goto walmart and buy a bag or wings for $10 for like 30 wings. Once in a while to order is ok. But I mostly cook at home. Eating out is too expensive now days.

Absolutely love their pizza! Best in town. I also wanna thank them for being a sponsor for my disc golf tournament at Como Lake Park. They gave a great deal on the pizza so we can afford to get plentiful for all participants! All other Pizza places made it impossible to talk the manager or owner but not them. They were eager to support disc golf and the thousands of us who travel to Lancaster to play every year.

Love the dough with the crust that disappears off the edge. Real Deal mozzarella. Tangy sauce with cup and Char pepperoni. There are garlic butter white pizza is killer. This restaurant checks all the boxes!

Pizza was Fantastic! If you like Bocce or Imperial Pizza, you will enjoy this pizza in Lancaster! 10/10

Excellent pizza, nearly on par with Picassos for flavor, but at a fair bit less money.

Probably the best blue cheese around to boot.

Already been twice in the last few weeks and will certainly be back in the future.

Let's start with the staff and service - everyone I interacted with was very welcoming and friendly.
Now, the food - we went with a C&P pizza with regular sauce..cheese was gooey and pepp had just a little bite. The Steak and Grass - doesn't look like a lot from the pic, but believe me, it's like a hungry man sub - bread soft, steak cooked perfectly and the added seasoned spinach gave my husband the "green thing" I make him eat every day. Give Papa's a try. You won't be disappointed.

We are super picky about local pizza, typically we never venture away from Piccasos, due to flavor. This pizza is as good if not better. They have a home made blue cheese that my wife is obsessed with. Overall a great pizza place that we have ordered at least 5 times since they opened. Sorry Piccassos, this place is why your business is slower...

Their is by far the best around, they do need to work on their organization with online orders, what's so far it's been worth any inconvenience because the pizza is fantastic.

Heard about this place on Facebook, not too close to me but decided to pickup a large pie(regular sauce) and wings(medium).

As a comparison I'll say the pizza taste almost the same as Imperial, I thought it was 👌🏻 pretty good, and the price wasn't outrageous at all!!

Wings were good, both size and taste.

The blue cheese was very interesting, I assume they make it themselves, it's got a zesty and garlic taste to it, I liked it, might not be your cup of yea if you're a traditional rooties fan. but nice change.
Would definitely recommend to anyone in the area

Truly amazing! From the call in, to the first bite. I don’t leave many reviews but I needed to on this one. Will be one of our weekly spots. Taste was amazing. Cheers!

The steak + five-cheese pizza is incredible. Each slice is like a full meal…of which I couldn’t help but eat 3 just because they were so good. Considering working out every day this week so I can order it again next weekend. Amazing food!!

I was skeptical of all the good reviews but decided to try it. Glad I did. Best pizza in this area. By a long shot. Traditional sauce has perfect tanginess and fantastic flavor. Crust is incredible with great char and crunch. The pepperoni is the best I've had. Give them your business and keep this place around!

If you live in the Buffalo area you have to try this place. I love sweet sauce growing up with a Sicilian Grandmother. after sitting in box in my car for almost a hour the bottom cold still had a crunch too it. And to top it all off i got it at 1am on w tuesday. Absolutely Amazing. Reminiscent of the way the original Bocce pizza was before they stopped rolling there dough and not cooking it through. Staff was amazing and one of the best regular pies I've had in a long time. Keep up the good work. #GOBILLS #GREATZA

This is the best new pizza joint in lancaster. Finally! You get your choice of regular or sweet sauce, their sweet sauce is amazing. Just needs a little bit more of it on the pizza. Had lots of cheese and the crust was soft and fluffy with the perfect crunch.
Their wings are very good and big and the wing sauces are nice and creamy and thick.
Wings come with a white sauce, taste is not quite blue cheese, not quite ranch, tastes like some Ceasar in there, perhaps a housemade blue cheese.. Im not sure, and as a die hard blue cheese fan, I was confused by it, but it was actually really delicious on the wings. I liked it!
They have great deals on half pizza/wing combos. Totally worth it! We've seen many pizza places come and go at this spot but this is the best!

Placed my online order and they were great in timing and letting me know order ready....LOVE THIS PIZZA!!! Everyone needs to try it, we ordered 3 different pizzas and could not pick a favorite cause they all had there unique perfection to them, cheese pizza has a wonderful red sauce. 5 cheese garlic pizza tasted like mac and cheese so good, and the chicken bacon ranch had ample toppings to it. Also ordered chicken tenders, great BBQ sauce on them...Our Family will definitely be back and highly recommend! Also we have family member with peanut/tree nut allergies and it was safe for my son which he was thrilled.

First of all, the only pizza place out of TWENTY that say they close at 10pm that we called at 9:15!!!!!! that even took our order.

This very pregnant mama was thrilled.

Then when I saw this delicious creation, I was in love. Just sent my husband back across town last night to get it again and IT DID NOT disappoint!!

It’s like classic buffalo style pizza but with its own little original twist without screwing it up.
Possible new favorite place??? For the customer service alone I think yes!

Thanks guys ❤ will be back again and again.