Gelateria Artigianale e Yogurteria WHY NOT?

I'm 10 days into a bicycling trip around Tuscany and this has been the best gelato I have found. The espresso mousse flavor is amazing. The owner is very friendly and prices are excellent!

Possibly the best ice cream I've ever had during my many visits to Italy. Fantastic! And very friendly service too.

Best gelato in Tuscany. Forget about San Gimignano. I also visited Lucca, Vinci, Siena, Firenze and this is the best Gelato. Pistachio was my favorite.

Delicious gelato with lots of options. Everyone in our group loved their gelato. They also have candy and pop for you to purchase. Highly recommend trying the gelato here if you are in Montalcino.

Best gelato I have tried so far!! The cappucino mousse and the hazelnut were wonderful together! This place was a great find!

A great gelato in Montelcino! Pistachio was better than what I had in Siena

Loved their gelato. Cappuccino mouse is a must try

Delicious ice cream, we liked pistachio the most!

Not to be missed! Amazing flavors, chocolate and pistachio on point 👌

Very intensive taste, don’t miss it when you are here.😋price is fair - 2.5€ for mid size.

All over Italy for 2 weeks, sometimes having gelato up to 3 times a day and this was easily the best gelato we had. The espresso mousse is incredible.

Very good ice cream and super affordable!

those ice creams are incredible! You must try pistachio! We tested 12 flavours and every one was good, some were amazing. Those are true Italian ice creams not frozed to death if you know what I mean.

Extremely popular place. Immediately you understand. Good quality gelato but overall unbeatable prices and the option for piccolo to keep sugar down! Friendly staff

The best gelato we had in Toscana. Will definitely go there again when visiting Montalcino ☺

Wow! Stumbled across this place walking back to our car one evening... full of locals enjoying a chat and eating gelato. The prices are cheap and I had a scoop of incredible pink grapefruit flavour which was genuinely unreal! Delizioso!

Small shop with excellent flavours. The cappuccino mousse is amazing - like licking the icing from a cake. Worth the climb!

Easily in the top 3 of all ice cream I had in Italy.

Hands down the best caffe (coffee) gelato we’ve had in Italy. Totally worth the trip to Montalcino to see Andrea and taste his handiwork. Wonderful nocciola (hazelnut) and amarena (cherry) as well. Been going there for years.

Excellent gelato. I loved the pistachio, one of the best I had while in Italy