Big John's Pizzeria

What a sweet surprise. Plenty of parking. Nice location. In the atmosphere inside is completely not what you expect. Fast service restaurant you order at the counter. Sit down and they bring it to you. Husband had chicken Parmesan. It looks like my grandmother made it, I had the shrimp Alfredo also equally homemade ,nice baked shrimp. Entrées come with three garlic knots and they are the best little bready garlic breads anywhere. Lovely atmosphere. Will return

Delish!

I must say we have encountered really terrible service at most every place we stopped at in The Keys. This restaurant was incredible; from taking our order, to serving our food, to saying goodbye.

I like they offer a single slice option. The salad was delicious and of course the mozzarella sticks were, too.

We may go back one more time before we travel back home!

We got the Hawaiian, Blue Pie, and the Margarita pizzas.
I loved the Blue pie but no one else in our party liked it. Strong Gorgonzola flavor.
The side salad hit the spot. Skip the prepackaged dressing and go for the olive oil and vinegar.
Garlic knots were also a must!!
Would return, good prices!

One of the best mom and pop pizzerias in the Florida Keys! Everything was delicious! The all-the-way pizza couldn’t have been better. Loaded with toppings on a New York style crust. The salad was perfect as an appetizer along with their famous garlic knots! Plenty of garlic butter and parmesan cheese on crispy outside yet doughy inside bread bites. The spaghetti was great with a huge portion and more garlic knots! All you can drink fountain pop as well! The staff was very friendly and polite when we ordered and took very good care of us. They also serve and sell a variety of wines and desserts! Located in Key Plaza, a must try pizza joint in the New Town of Key West. Very pleased and will definitely be back next time!

Big John’s Pizzeria Is Great! Their pizza is good. The interior is decorated beautifully with the lights, and all the great Italian decorations. There’s indoor and outdoor seating. Without doubt I recommend Big John’s Pizzeria. Have a great day!

The best pizza in Key West! This has been our families go to. We have tried a few places over the years and nothing compares.

Yum! Our family ordered takeout after a day at the beach and everything we ordered exceeded expectations. Reasonable prices—especially in the Keys! Would recommend adding the garlic bread knots to your order!

Amazing pizzeria! Wings, pizza, and garlic knots were so good. I heard the garlic knots are a popular item here and I can see why!

Located in Key West, Fla. I was told by the locals that this was the place to go for pizza in Key West, and they were definitely correct. This is a very attractive atmosphere and is very, very clean. The prices are good and the New York style pizza was amazing. The presentation of the pizza itself in the box was very professional, showing much pride in the craft of good product. If you appreciate good pizza, give this place a visit. The price is modest and the quality is fantastic.

Photos should speak for themselves. For 25+ years of experience, this place knows what they’re doing. Best place for good food & a good time. Next time you’re in key west & want GOOD new york style italian food, eat at BIG JOHN’S!!

As a Conch Local that's traveled and eaten lots of good Italian.. Omg what a surprise, this was so good! I'm stuffed and so happy I tried this place out! Exceeded my expectations and so glad we have a place this good for Italian for the people! Omg once again seriously I'm taking everyone here when they visit! Eggplant Parm with Garlic knots was omg so good I'm going back again tomorrow for the same thing.

It was hot as hell inside, ac may have been down. They made my pizza wrong and I had to wait for another to be made. The pizza, however was the bomb, it was delicious!

This is the best pizza I have tried in all of the keys. You can tell that the ingredients are fresh and very good quality. It's very cliche to say the best New York style pizza but honestly the crust is some of the best I have ever eaten. Thank you BIG JOHN!

I have eaten in and had delivery from here. So good!!! The ultimate we had in restaurant and was absolutely delicious, so much flavor. The stuffed pizza was also delicious, with the perfect marrying of flavors. The only thing I would like to say was bad was that we only were given two tiny containers of sauce. For the size of the pizza, the hefty amounts of ingredients, we could easily used a quart of sauce! Lol.

Friendly staff great service great food ! Our family had fettuccine Alfredo, shrimp Alfredo, spaghetti and meatballs, and pizza.

Great atmosphere, incredible food, you get out of there with a full belly. Order a dinner plate, get salad and garlic rolls

Pizza was so good , the marinara was also tasty . I would definitely go back when in town !

Wife and I had the 2 slices and soda special. Very close to NY city experience.
Daughter had the chicken fettuccine and said it was "amazing."

Awesome pizza, fast delivery. They also brought plenty of plates and napkins which I forgot to ask for.

Great Food and Staff! We eat here any time we're in the area! Fresh Salads and Pizza. Highly recommend!