Bennett Shellfish

Best Lobster rolls in town! Cute house, only pick-up. Don't need to say more, just check it out! Two rolls with chips as side dish for 30$.

Does not get better than this!! Best lobster rolls in Montauk plus the best price!! 2 for $30??? You can’t get one for that anywhere else! They also have amazing fresh catches , I love getting their tuna and make some poke bowls or sashimi! Recently got some live lobsters from them and they were HUGE and so sweet!! Plus the owners Kimberly & Clint are the sweetest couple. They’ve been here for 14 generations!!! Love them and it’s a weekly stop for me and my husband xx tita!!

WOW! First of all, you can’t beat the price! 2 lobster rolls for $30! One of the restaurants in town sells one lobster roll for $50 and chances are, it’s not as good as this! So fresh and delicious!! And wonderful customer service!

2x$30 Lobster Rolls!! Amazing! Lobster Rolls Are Super Good! At a Third Of The Price as your Average MTK Lobster Roll you cant Get Any Better Than This! Gracias Kim. Its like Picking Up Your Food In The Cleanest Kitchen you Will See. I wish i would of ate here everyday. Casn Only , Take Out Only! Did I Say 2x$30 Lobster Rolls. Dont miss out on the Best Deal In The East End!!

We often camp out in Montauk and are blessed to have come across Bennett Shellfish. Kim and Clint are the best! The 14th generation bayman traditions and sustainable practices they execute on a daily basis are meaningful and much needed. Great, family oriented customer service you don't find as much of anymore. They took their time answering our questions, giving us advice and tips. The smoked bluefish, lobster rolls and oysters are easily the best we have ever had. Clint meticulously put together a seafood boil to go that we cooked over our campfire. Was absolutely amazing!! We wish we lived closer to them. We can't wait to get back there to try their famous clam pies and all the other topnotch seafood. Truly a water to table experience that cannot be missed or replicated. Thank you guys!!

Nice little shop for fresh seafood and desserts. Lobster rolls were very good, although the buns weren't toasted. Much more affordable than any restaurant in town.

The freshest clams and oysters found in Montauk, and maybe because they were shucked with such love and care from the owner, Kim. She was incredibly hospitable, and her husband kindly set up our table outside to enjoy the seafood. She even offered us a sample of smoked fish which was out of this world! Adorable place, super clean with various products to purchase. Thank you so much, we will come back to try other things!!!! 🙏❤

it was an amazing experience! the oysters are fresh, literally caught in the ocean right now. the hostess was nice and friendly. I recommend!

The BEST raw oysters I have ever tasted. Lobster roll was super fresh as well and wasn't drenched in mayo. The ratio of lobster, how it was cut, the celery and mayo was perfect. Kim was wonderful as well; very personable. The place is immaculate!! Best sea food market I've ever been to.

Came in on Tuesday September 10, and bought 4 dozen oysters and smoked bluefish dip. The oysters were superb. Fresh, briney, and plump. They’re wild caught not farmed. Excellent! Their smoked bluefish was also fantastic. Smokey without being over powering, savory and delicious. I paired with some cheese and charcuterie and it was a fine addition. Bennett seafood is a family owned business that you can see is run with care and love. I highly recommend if you’re looking for fresh delicious seafood.

Everything you buy at Bennett’s is as fresh as can be! we had the clam pie, which was so delicious. The crust was buttery and flaky and the inside had lots of creamy clams and potatoes. I definitely recommend the clam pie. We also enjoyed the smoke whiting it was perfectly smoked and tasty. We also immensely enjoyed the blue fin dip. We had it on crackers quite delectable! You will not be disappointed with anything you get a Bennett Seafood!

Visited this afternoon for some fresh oysters and everything was amazing! The owners were a true delight and shucked and plated our oysters and clams on the spot so they were ready for us to enjoy back at our hotel. So happy to have met them. If you are in Montauk and need fresh shellfish or fish, this place is a great find.

Kimberley was extremely kind and hospitable. Lobster rolls and tuna were fresh and delicious. A must stop when in mtk!

The best bang for the buck in Montauk …… 2 for 1 lobster rolls at an affordable price. Generous servings of fresh lobster on fresh potato bread.

If you’ve never had a clam pie ……… try one ! It’s a Montauk delicacy.

what can i say than : always the BEST, the FRESHEST, the cleanest, the nicest. so so glad to know them, their place, and their seafood --the only kind we like to eat and know is freshhhhhh. delicious, delightful and plain ole fabulous

Stumbled upon this place on google and accidentally ended up having the BEST oysters! Everything was super fresh, and we grabbed the smoked fish dip too. The owners were extremely kind and knowledgeable; highly recommend to anyone in town

Best fish dip we have ever had, and the oysters were incredible. Kimberly was fun to talk to. Fish is all super fresh and amazing quality!

Shoutout to Jane the pickle maker too - fantastic.

This is what Montauk is all about. Delicious, fresh seafood and fantastic people behind it. It’s sometimes hard to find value as a visitor in Montauk, however look no further than Bennett and the very fair priced lobster rolls and seafood. The lobster rolls are the best I ever had, truly, and priced at a fraction of the tourist spots in town. I’ll be stopping at Bennett every time I’m in Montauk.

Best place to go for oysters in Montauk!! Skip the hoity toity white glove treatment and go eat with the locals🦪

Absolutely awesome if you like your lobster roll cold it’s the absolute best out east ! The star of the show was the smoked fish dip! Don’t miss it !