HMC

Rowdy Hall

Bar & grill in Gardiners Island

Updated: October 05, 2024 03:55 AM

Rowdy Hall is located in Gardiners Island (Island in Suffolk County, New York), United States. It's address is 177 Main St, Amagansett, NY 11930.

177 Main St, Amagansett, NY 11930

XVG5+36 Amagansett, New York

(631) 324-8555

places.singleplatform.com

rowdyhall.com

Check Time Table for Rowdy Hall


Monday3 to 9 PM
Tuesday3 to 9 PM
Wednesday3 to 9 PM
Thursday3 to 9 PM
Friday12 to 10 PM
Saturday12 to 10 PM
Sunday12 to 9 PM

Questions & Answers


Where is Rowdy Hall?

Rowdy Hall is located at: 177 Main St, Amagansett, NY 11930.

What is the phone number of Rowdy Hall?

You can try to calling this number: (631) 324-8555

What are the coordinates of Rowdy Hall?

Coordinates: 40.9751274, -72.1419372

Rowdy Hall Reviews

Ann Travers
2024-09-20 00:30:04 GMT

Delicious meatloaf! Service was excellent. We had my 17 month old grandson with us, and they were very sweet to him. They wouldn’t let us clean up the food he dropped on the floor. Just very kind.

Kimberly Minson
2023-09-19 20:44:02 GMT

I ordered the unique take on a salad. Loved it. I had a bite of my friend's tuna and it was really special. Four of us shared the s'mores dessert plus the peanut butter ice cream. Uh-mazing.
We went a second time and the food was wonderful, but our server must have been new. We waited around a long time for her to come for the dessert order (she was just standing by the computer chatting with somebody forever) after which she told us that the peanut butter ice cream was sold out which put us all in kind of a bad temper. I did end up ordering the chocolate cake which was absolutely delicious (but I was really hoping to have it topped with peanut butter ice cream). Once she finally brought the checks upon request, they haven't been divided properly, she billed for water, etc.

Adrian Alonso
2021-05-30 00:16:48 GMT

Buffalo chicken wings were really nice and they'll customise the level of spiciness to your liking. The burger was one one the best I've had for quite some time, cooked to perfection and with all the elements of high quality, the tomato was really tasty and so were the onion and pickle. The chili was ok, although it could have been a bit spicier. The dessert, a Blondie Sundae, was also scrumptious! And all the staff were very friendly and attentive. Really good pub experience!

Billy Kim
2024-07-27 23:14:53 GMT

Went twice in two days. Overall, comfortable atmosphere and good food. Recommend.

Jennifer Dickens
2024-03-27 22:28:42 GMT

Came here for appetizers and took entrees to go. All the food was delicious, especially the fish and chips (I was especially fond of the tartar sauce!) While a little expensive, I'd go again.

Nancy Fedder
2023-12-14 01:30:39 GMT

EVEN BETTER NOW IN AMAGANSETT - I have been a regular who has always enjoyed Rowdy Hall. It is one of the few places in EH where you can enjoy a meal and just feel comfortable. When I heard they were moving I was upset but I think they are so much better in Amagansett because the vibe was always off a bit in EH. So now that they moved I finally went and I just love it even more. The menu has been "refreshed" and the food and atmosphere are great. What a fun block they are on. At 6PM it was packed. We were greeted by the GM Kim who gets it. Her energy is infectious. You can tell that she truly loves what she does. Not an ounce of "attitude" and she runs the place like a pro. In this new location it will be my "go to" restaurant even though it is a little further away. Prices are not inflated and you can never go wrong with the Rowdy Burger. In fact based on tasting what everyone had, you can't go wrong. Enjoy!

Anthony DeStefano
2023-12-12 10:00:43 GMT

Had a random craving for fish n chips and was recommended this place by a friend. I can’t stress enough how absolutely dead on this place was. Food was EXACTLY what I had in mind and more. Service was friendly and prompt. Outside seating was refreshing. 10/10!!

Nancy Atlas
2024-01-16 22:50:10 GMT

The absolute best french onion soup i've ever had. Everything on the menu was completely on point. Love the staff. Love the owners. Love the vibe. Above and beyond a pub.

Z C
2023-09-10 02:28:48 GMT

The original restaurant we were planning to go to had a power outage, so Rowdy let us sit down for a last minute dinner. We just wanted a simple dinner. What we got were spectacular burgers, strong pours, and warm customer service. We’ll be back.

Ben Creedy
2023-08-09 23:18:36 GMT

The food was outstanding in a fun, family-friendly atmosphere. I had the fried chicken and chocolate fudge cake for dessert. All of it was delicious. I highly recommend Rowdy Hall!

Michael Dorgan
2021-04-03 21:10:08 GMT

Absolutely top class food, amazing. Joe behind the bar was a gentleman too. Highly recommended

George Morris
2024-03-24 13:37:05 GMT

Great bartenders ! Everything was excellent, I am so glad we stopped at Rowdy Hall.

Brendan Walsh
2023-01-14 01:43:52 GMT

Being going there for Saturday lunches for the longest time - terrific value and quality!
This evening (Friday the 13th as it happens) we came for dinner. On the recommendations of Sam and the manager Christopher, I ordered the pan- roasted chicken! Wow! Simply amazing in so many ways!

Jim Mohan
2021-04-11 00:58:03 GMT

Had just a lovely meal here tonight. French onion soup was slamming, steak frites was awesome. Service was great. It was the 1st time we ate inside a restaurant in over a year since the pandemic started. Thank you for making a lovely evening

Kenzie “KTazWV” Cook
2024-07-18 20:08:43 GMT

Food was great sat at the bar.

CONTEXTERRIOR
2022-01-08 03:16:09 GMT

after living in Germany for 10+ years was happy to find this restaurant, it's official!
Lovely food and great ambience for a Friday night. Good beer on tap and nice entrees.

Charlotte Martin
2019-10-16 14:55:55 GMT

I've come here many times for fish and chips, one of my favorite meals in the area. They also screen soccer matches, I've watched two world cups here over the summer, it gets packed during peak hours and more packed during soccer games. Nice very English authentic pub decor, and nestled in a little square that makes the whole thing very picturesque.

vincent rennie
2019-07-06 18:19:10 GMT

Great bar! With good food options. And the bartender is a cocktail dictionary.

APJ
2018-05-09 02:05:43 GMT

We were guided here by an East Hampton local, and it was probably one of the favorite restaurants we visited during a week long trip. Rowdy hall is low-brow and approachable, but serves a nice variety of well prepared and seemingly high quality food. We tried several items and were very satisfied with everything (try the buffalo chicken dip), and prices were more reasonable than many other, less delicious options in the area. I highly recommend this place if it seems like your kinda spot, and will definitely be back the next time I'm around.

Steven A. Ludsin
2021-09-28 09:03:03 GMT

One of my favorite restaurants. The staff is friendly and the service is just right. The burgers are always great as well as the onion soup and the food that matches the season like Oktoberfest.

Write a review of Rowdy Hall


Rowdy Hall Directions
About Gardiners Island
Island in Suffolk County, New York

Gardiner's Island is a small island in the Town of East Hampton, New York, in Eastern Suffolk County. It is located in Gardiner's Bay between the two peninsulas at the east end of Long Island. source

Top Rated Addresses in Gardiners Island