Papa John's Pizza

Better ingredients, better pizza just like the motto and the staff was very friendly.
Food was ready by the time indicated or sooner. Very good pizza and that's not just because I haven't had pizza in who knows how long lol!
I've ordered here two days in a row because I had a gift card from donating blood and I'm new here as well as being homeless.
I feel the prices are good also because I could make a pizza last two meals which is great when your not sure where your next meal is coming from.
Not sure why this place only has three stars but I'm assuming maybe it was back when they a staff like McDonald's, IHOP or Wendy's which are all horribly ran with poor ratings etc.

Great place to pick up a pizza and a salad north end of town in Key West. Excellent pizza, friendly efficient service and a comfortable dining area if you want to eat in. nothing fancy but worth the trip. The dining area can accommodate a lot of people, plenty of parking if you have a car, you don’t have to hassle to go downtown.

Very friendly service. Pretty fast and efficient and plus they have the highest military discount in key west I’ve seen so far. 30% off all active duty and veterans. Definitely recommend

The staff was very friendly. When my paper bag ripped apart, he gifted me a proper bag and even gave me a smaller pizza box to fit it in than normally. This was very nice and welcoming, so I appreciated the food an extra bit more.

Dave went above and beyond to ensure that our order was perfect and that we had the best experience from this Papa John's and so did our delivery driver. Highly recommend for customer service and a great dinner at home.

Very nice I always go after school and their food is very good and made pretty fast they always make sure we get good deals and treat us like we’re close friends I try to go there everyday

Love Papa John's pizza

I’d like to mention the most pristine and friendly order with Dave, the most professional customer service representative, seriously, thank you!

The best gluten free Alfredo pizza I’ve ever had. Edge to edge cheese and not burnt like a lot of gluten free pizzas I’ve had before. Sorry I didn’t get to take a picture of the actual pizza. It was gone shortly after I received a very quick delivery. I also loved the spicy garlic sauce. It’s better than the original but wow is it spicy! But I love spicy stuff. The only thing is I ordered a cheese sauce and I only got a spicy garlic which I’d ordered and a garlic sauce. I don’t know if the garlic sauce still comes with the pizza. I really did want that cheese sauce! It was ordered correctly too. Maybe I can get it with my next order? I don’t live in key west I visit friends every couple of months.

Food was amazing! Carl made excellent suggestions and was very friendly.

Carl and Shawn were great! Fast service and their recommendations were great!! Pizza and wings were hot and tasty!

I was here New Year's Eve at around 8pm. There was only one woman there at the store. She rocked it. They were off the chain crazy. Yet, she did it all by herself. It is awful that she was there by herself same on you manager and staff. Big props to my girl. I don't know how she handled it. I know she was stressed but she wasn't showing it at all. Professional all the way. Very pleasant. Super efficient she was making boxes tagging boxes before the pizzas workout stacking boxes to make sure she was completely organized so that not a second of her time would be wasted. plus my pizza was hot delicious and in better shape than when I've gone there and there were multiple people working. Great experience but still shame shame on you management and staff.

Great pizzas and costumer service. I would definitely come here again. The only fall back is that I always have to wait 30 minutes for my pizza but oh I tell you it is worth the wait! It’s so so so good! This place deserves way more stars, hopefully people change their minds about this great place 👍

Great service for pizza delivery. Customer service is always on point. They're nice and accommodating. Always able to satisfy all our needs. And who doesn't love the peppers and garlic dipping sauce for their pizza.

Delivery and lunch specials are where this place shines. Be patient with the English as a second language staff and you will be rewarded with good food. The stuffed pizzas are great, order an extra side of sauce to go with the stuffed pizzas, and try adding or replacing one ingredient with extra meat.

Accidentally ordered online from my local papas and waited and waited lol. Once we figured it out, both stores were very nice and key west papa johns was very nice, and worth the wait. Awesome pizza, and a great staff tonight.

All ya'll that are Down Here in Key West on Vacation, The One Thing you NEED to understand straight off is that you are on a Very. Desirable. Little piece of real estate.... Where rent for a Meager studio apartment on that Island is $1800 a month ... (And there may ONLY BE 1 or 2 apartments available for rent over the course of six months on that Entire Island... LOOK IT UP!)
It's more expensive here to live in Key West than New York or San Francisco, I should know I Lived there for years... so Be Grateful for the people ya Got working behind the counter WHEREVER YOU GO or ESPECIALLY Delivering yer pizza ...
You CANNOT Just FIND STAFF that can Afford $1800. a month, PLUS Utilities, PLUS Owning, Insuring, an Parking a Car on that Island...

Ive got 20 years Experience Delivering pizza, and Lived in Key West 5 years doing just that, Id Be There HELPING OUT RIGHT NOW but there is NO PLACE TO LIVE on that Island or within a 1 Hour Commute FROM it that I can Afford on what I would make as a Delivery Driver ... are we supposed to BOAT IN from CUBA everyday ???

GIVE THESE PEOPLE A BREAK ! They are Doing The Best Best that they can !

And you should Already Know ANYPLACE that your ordering from in a National Food Chain is going to give you an UNREALISTIC DELIVERY TIME like 30 minutes To Insure your going to Order from "them" and no other Chain store..
Even when they probably DON'T HAVE THE STAFF to do it in the Amount of time they promised.

(Only person this all Hurts is the Driver ... Everytime, Because he's given your food to Deliver out of the oven 40 minutes AFTER you ordered it, when it was supposed to be delivered 10 minutes BEFORE he even got it...)

KEEP ON ORDERING ONLINE and COMPLAINING ONLINE and DESTROYING OUR LIVLIHOOD ...

or MAYBE YOU COULD HAVE ROBOTS Deliver your Food.. To Go Along with yer Whole ~ONLINE~ Experience ...

THANKS A LOT !!!

I love me some papa johns. Owner is amazing. Staff is amazing and best of all, the pizza is amazing. They deliver on the base too which is great. Keep up the outstanding job.

I was nervous to order here because of the bad reviews but it was great. It came quickly, the driver was nice, and tasted like any other Papa John's.

They said 35 mins for delivery, he was here in 20 mins with a hot fresh pizza. Nice staff. Great tasting fresh pizza. They even asked if we needed any drinks delivered.